2025 Reading Challenge Crossover Books

If you’re participating in our 2025 Book Lover’s Challenge, this crossover list highlights the books that fit the monthly Book Lovers prompt AND one of the monthly prompts for our other yearlong reading challenges. We hope this helps during those months that you need to double-dip and provides a quick shortcut to stay on track with the challenges even when life gets busy.

We will update this page each month after curating the recommended reading list for the Book Lover’s Challenge, and you’ll always find the most recent month at the top of the page. Use the table of contents above if you’d like to jump directly to a specific past month.

We initially planned to identify all crossover books for the various challenges, but with six total yearlong challenges, there are 15 different combinations possible each month. Not only does it feel overwhelming for us to check for all potential crossovers each month, but it also feels like the resulting list would be overwhelming and confusing for you. However, you are always welcome to count any crossovers you find between the existing challenges.

May Crossover Books

The following books specifically satisfy this month’s Book Lover’s prompt, as well as a reading prompt for one of our other challenges:

*We’ve used asterisks below to note which challenge list the book originally appeared on

We All Live Here book cover

Book Summary

Lila’s family is complicated, her house is falling apart, and career as a self-help writer is at a standstill because she’s developed writer’s block. She’s divorced, has two willfull daughters, and her elderly stepfather seems to have quietly moved in with her. Then her real father – a man she hasn’t seen since he left for Hollywood more than three decades ago – suddenly shows up on her doorstep.

His reappearance in her life after 35 years feels like the final straw. But she’ll learn that even when you think you can’t forgive someone, they might still have something to teach you about love and what it means to be family.

The Book Girls Say…

Jojo Moyes is skilled at creating multidimensional, relatable characters and crafting emotional novels that make you feel all the feels. This one promises to make you laugh and cry.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Best Book Club Books for 2025

Three Lives of Cate Kay book cover

Book Summary

Everyone knows Cate Kay as the author of a best-selling book trilogy that turned into a box office gold film series. She’s one of the most successful authors of her generation, except that no one actually knows Cate Kay… because Cate Kay doesn’t exist. Her real identity has been a carefully guarded secret until now.

Growing up, she and her best friend Amanda shared their dreams of moving to California and becoming movie stars. But before their lives can ever really begin, a tragedy shatters those dreams. Cate has been on the run ever since, using different names to craft a new future. But now a shocking revelation will force Cate to return home. It’s the only way she’ll be a whole person again.

The Book Girls Say…

This character-driven novel takes readers on a psychological journey and addresses themes of ambition, self-discovery, and sexual identity. While it incorporates elements of mystery, it fits more into the literary fiction genre than the traditional mystery genre.

Autoboyography book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

3.9 out of 5
97%
Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Tanner Scott’s family relocated from progressive California to conservative Utah three years ago. Life in Provo (home to BYU) is complicated enough as a half-Jewish, half-lapsed Mormon teenager, so Tanner, who was openly bisexual at his previous school, decides to go back into the closet at Provo High. Now, in his senior year, he is looking forward to attending an out-of-state college next year, where he can once again feel free to be himself.

He fully intends to coast through his final semester of high school classes until his best friend, Autumn, dares him to take a prestigious honors seminar where students draft an entire book in just four months. And his final semester plans are pushed even further off track when Tanner finds himself falling in love with Sebastian Brother, the class mentor who sold his seminar novel to a major publishing house the year before. He’s also the son of an LDS Bishop.

The Book Girls Say…

This young adult novel is a mostly closed-door romance. Some reviewers say it felt too much like a predictable romance in the initial chapters, but multiple points of conflict make it a very engaging read as the plot moves forward. 

Christina Lauren is the pen name for long-time writing partners Christina Hobbs and Lauren Billings. Christina is a former middle school counselor in her home state of Utah, and Lauren, a Ph.D. and mother of two in California, identifies as bisexual. In an interview, the authors described doing extensive research for Autoboyography, including reading the diaries of a friend who came out as gay after his LDS mission.

Girls' Guide to Winning the War book cover

Book Summary

Peggy is a librarian whose twin brother is fighting on the front lines of WW2 in 1940. When she’s given the opportunity to take on a new job assisting in the war effort herself as a proofreader for the Ministry of Information and in the Publications Department, she’s thrilled to be able to play a part in ending the war and helping her brother return home safely.

However, now she reports to socialite Lady Marigold Cecily, who seems more interested in dancing than ending the war. Peggy finds solace in writing, but when the Ministry of Information publishes her inner thoughts without her knowledge, she realizes she needs Lady Marigold’s help.

The Book Girls Say…

In addition to Peggy’s story, this novel also includes information on the other jobs women took on during the war, from working in factories to driving to air raid wardens. Overall, it’s a heartwarming story of determination, friendship, and family, but you’ll feel plenty of other emotions along the way as well.

Many Lives of Mama Love book cover

Book Summary

Lara looked like a typical soccer mom in Santa Cruz, California, complete with a million-dollar home in a cul-de-sac. But one day, everything she had been hiding came tumbling down. Lara had been stealing neighbors’ credit cards in order to support her heroin addiction.

She was convicted of 32 felonies and had to quickly learn the ways of prison politics and its class system. She earns the nickname “Mama Love” from other inmates and soon rises to become the “shot caller”.

After serving her sentence, 42-year-old Lara reinvents herself again as a ghost-writer. She’s gone from stealing others’ identities for heroin to becoming others to help them right hit novels. She was successful enough to meet Oprah, the Dalai Lama, and Archbishop Desmond Tutu. Through all this, the shame of her past haunts her. She must learn to forgive before she can truly move on.

The Book Girls Say…

This 2023 memoir continues to receive incredibly high ratings, with many saying it reads like page-turning fiction. While much of the book talks about her time in prison, writing also plays an important role in that period of her life.

In addition to becoming an author, Lara Love Hardin is also a prison reform advocate and co-founder of The Gemma Project, which serves incarcerated and formerly incarcerated women with integrity and compassion.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

23 Books With Love in the Title

Harlem Rhapsody book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

4.4 out of 5
93%
Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

While much of the country was experiencing social unrest in 1919, Harlem felt different. This corner of New York was filled with Black pride, as evidenced in the music, theater, fashion, and arts. Positioned right in the heart of this renaissance is a literary editor for a preeminent Negro magazine named Jessie Redmon Fauset.

The magazine’s founder and editor, W.E.B. Du Bois, tasked Jessie with discovering promising young writers whose words could change the world. Jessie wastes no time finding 16-year-old Countee Cullen and 17-year-old Langston Hughes. She also discovers Nella Larsen, who becomes one of Jessie’s best friends.

Subscriptions soar for the already notable magazine, and every Black writer in the country is vying for the opportunity to be published in The Crisis. Jessie’s career is taking off, but her relationship with her married boss, W.E.B., threatens to jeopardize it all. At a time when she faces both overwhelming sexism and racism, Jessie will have to find a way to balance her drive and her desires if she hopes to preserve her legacy and achieve her ambitious dreams.

The Book Girls Say…

This novel is based on the real life of Jessie Redmon Fauset. Those interested in digging deeper into the true stories and literary works behind this novel will be excited to learn that every edition of The Crisis is available online.

Victoria Christopher Murray has co-authored two of our favorite books from recent years (The Personal Librarian and The First Ladies). Melissa also enjoyed learning more about literary history in Harlem Rhapsody. Despite the main publishing house in this novel being focused on a magazine, there is plenty of talk about books as well.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Best Book Club Books for 2025

Jane and Dan at the End of the World book cover

Book Summary

Forty-something Jane had dreams of being a writer, but feels like her whole life is in flux as her one published work only sold 500 copies. She also believes her husband of 19ish years, Dan, is cheating on her. When they go to an upscale restaurant for their anniversary, it seems like a good time to tell him she wants a divorce.

But before the second course arrives, an underground climate activist group bursts into the dining room, taking the whole restaurant hostage…but in a bumbling sort of way. Jane is shocked. Not because she’s suddenly a hostage, but because everything the activists say and do is straight from the pages of her novel. This means she knows what is going to happen next, and it’s up to her to stop it.

The Book Girls Say…

Angela loved this 2025 release from the author of The Mostly True Story of Tanner & Louise & The Invisible Husband of Frick Island! It’s classified as both a mystery and a romance, although on the romance side, it’s really about the ups and downs of a long-term relationship in mid-life.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Novels With Characters Becoming Part of the Story

By the Book Mysteries book covers

Book Summary

Forty-something Tess Harrow is a bestselling thriller writer, but this summer, she just wants to take a break to bond with her daughter after her recent divorce. They’ve barely settled in when an explosion rocks the cabin, and Tess finds herself pulled into a murder investigation.

The local sheriff turns out to be the spitting image of the detective Tess writes about in her books, her young daughter is fascinated by dead bodies, and the neighbors are pointing their fingers at Bigfoot. Nothing about this summer is going as she had planned.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Summer Cozy Mysteries Set on the Beach

The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

4.3 out of 5
96%
Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Evelyn Hugo lived a glamorous and scandalous life, but doesn’t like to talk about it, and has become reclusive after leaving her career. When the movie icon is finally ready to talk about her time in show business, she picks an unknown reporter to log her personal history, but why?

You’ll slowly unwrap Evelyn’s life from the 1950s – 1980s as she chronicles her past life and relationships, including the seven husbands she had along the way. As the book covers so much of her life, it moves quickly and will keep you engaged and entertained for hours.

Genius of Judy book cover

Book Summary

If Judy Blume is one of the authors who first sparked your love of reading, then you’ll want to pick up this biography, which provides an intimate portrait of her life, her work, and her cultural impact.

It begins in the 1960s, when Judy, a mother of two living in suburban New Jersey, was searching for more purpose in her life. She began writing books that starred regular children with genuine thoughts and problems. But more than that, she used her deceptively simple tales to provide honest exploration of the growing women’s rights movement and address issues like career opportunities, bodily autonomy, and even sexual pleasure.

Blume’s bravery provoked backlash, making her the country’s most-banned author in the mid-1980s. Thankfully, her works withstood those culture wars, and she remains a beloved author among readers of all ages. Now, this biography tells the story of how she went from housewife to a groundbreaking icon.

Book Summary

Harper is a young author with one major best-seller under her belt, but now she’s in need of a career comeback. At the suggestion of her agent, she rents a house in New Canaan, Connecticut. Hiding her author identity from everyone she meets, Harper seeks to draw inspiration for a new novel about women in the suburbs.

Soon, Harper befriends her empty-nester neighbor. It’s October, and Wendy’s son just moved away for college. She’s struggling with being all alone, but not just because she misses her son. Wendy is keeping a secret of her own—her struggle with kleptomania.

The Book Girls Say…

Angela was initially drawn in by the kleptomania/mental health focus of this novel, which was very well done. Ultimately, however, it was the intergenerational relationship element of this story that she enjoyed the most.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 04/02/2025

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Cozy Books to Read in the Fall of 2024

Misery book cover

Book Summary

Bestselling novelist 42-year -old Paul Sheldon finds himself in a nightmarish situation when he is rescued from a car crash by Annie Wilkes, a reclusive former nurse and his self-proclaimed “number one fan.”

Paul had just completed a new, non-romance manuscript and killed off Misery Chastain, the heroine of his famous series. But Annie, obsessed with Misery, is furious. Holding Paul captive in her remote Colorado home, she demands he write a new novel resurrecting Misery, under constant threat of violence if she disapproves of his work.

Trapped and severely injured, Paul is forced to use his wits and storytelling skills not only to appease Annie, but to survive.

The Book Girls Say…

Stephen King frequently features writers as protagonists or central characters in his novels. If horror is not your preferred genre, consider his 2021 work of crime fiction, Billy Summers. In this book, Billy is a former Marine sniper and Iraq war vet turned hitman who only kills “bad people.” He’s taking one last job before retiring that requires him to go undercover as a writer named David Lockridge. Under his assumed author name, he rents office space in the small town of Red Buff. The story alternates between Billy’s real life and the fictional memoir that he is penning, which tells his backstory.

Don't Forget to Write book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

4.4 out of 5
97%
Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Marilyn wasn’t just caught making out with the rabbi’s son—she was caught by the whole congregation! In hopes of saving their daughter’s reputation, her parents sent her to her great-aunt Ada for the summer. They gave her an ultimatum: spend the summer with Ada, the strict, premier matchmaker, or kiss her college plans goodbye.

Based on her mother’s description, Marilyn expects Ada to be a humorless septuagenarian. Instead, Ada is sharp and straight-talking, with platinum blonde hair, a Hermès scarf, and a Cadillac convertible.

Ada and Marilyn set off for Avalon on the Jersey Shore, where Marilyn helps to scope out eligible matches for anyone but herself. She’s learning a lot from Ada—but not exactly what her parents were hoping for. Marilyn realizes that she doesn’t have to settle, even as her father threatens to disinherit her.

The Book Girls Say…

Marilyn’s dream of attending college is fueled by her desire to become an author. Her father does not understand her modern ideals and would much rather see her become a housewife, as was expected of most girls at the time. Her passion for writing is a big plot point throughout the book.

We love summertime historical fiction, so we were very excited when our readers voted this one of the Best Beach Reads of All Time. Melissa read it based on those recommendations and liked it so much that she immediately started working through every Sara Goodman Confino book.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 04/07/2025

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

4.2 out of 5
92%
Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

After years of struggling to make it as a writer, James has finally sold his first book – a semi-autobiographical novel about his dysfunctional relationship with his mother. He’s shocked to find out that the editor who has purchased his book is none other than Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis.

After an embarrassing initial meeting, James and Mrs. Onassis, as she’s known around the office, form an unexpected friendship. By the time his book is finally published, his relationship with his editor has changed him as a writer and as a son.

The Book Girls Say…

It can be tricky to write historical fiction in which one of the main characters is a famous, real-life person. While Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis did, in fact, work as a book editor at Viking Press and Doubleday after her second husband’s death, Steven Rowley did a fantastic job portraying his fictionalized Jackie O as a private, professional woman full of heart.

Love in the City book cover

Book Summary

When bookshop employee and aspiring writer Alex is dumped on her 30th birthday, she makes some huge life decisions…while drunk. The next morning, she decides to go all in on the plans to escape her New Zealand hometown and hop on the plane to New York City. It’s finally time to pursue her dream of writing a novel!

Determined to build a career, she focuses on crafting stories about single life in the city. Her plans take an unexpected turn when she meets Michael, her grumpy yet attractive upstairs neighbor and single father. As their paths intertwine, Michael begins featuring in her fantasies. Maybe he’s exactly the inspiration she needs to write a sexy romance novel.

The Book Girls Say…

The characters in Love in the City are entertaining and fundamentally good people with relatable flaws. This is a slow-burn that ultimately ignites into steamy flames. Romance novel perfection!

If you enjoy this book, there are three more in the series, although this is the only one about a writer.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 04/10/2025
Seven Days in June book cover

Book Summary

Eva is a single mother and bestselling erotica author based in Brooklyn. Her life takes an unexpected turn when she encounters Shane Hall, a reclusive, award-winning novelist, at a literary event. Unbeknownst to the public, Eva and Shane shared a passionate week-long romance as teenagers twenty years prior—a connection they’ve subtly referenced in their writings over the years.

As they reconnect over the course of seven days during a sweltering Brooklyn summer, unresolved feelings and past traumas resurface. Eva grapples with trusting Shane again, especially given the heartbreak he once caused her. Amidst their rekindled chemistry, both must confront their personal demons and decide if they can forge a future together.

The Book Girls Say…

Featuring complex characters and raw emotions, this literary romance novel is praised by reviewers for its blend of humor, depth, and sensuality. It contains lots of steamy scenes, so keep that in mind before deciding if it’s the right book for you.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 04/07/2025
On Fire Island book cover

Book Summary

As a thirty-seven-year-old book editor, Julia thought she had a long life ahead of her. But then the unthinkable happens, and she passes away after a cancer diagnosis. While Julie could have followed the proverbial light at the end of the tunnel, she instead had the opportunity to observe her family one final summer at their Fire Island home.

She’ll see how her novelist husband Ben and neighbor Shep navigate grieving as new widowers, along with the lives of their other friends and neighbors. You’ll also see the ways her career as a book editor impacted her life.

The Book Girls Say…

While we wish this weren’t true, too many families have to deal with an unexpected diagnosis and loss. Instead of focusing on Julia’s decline, this character-driven novel gives us a unique perspective of seeing a summer she would have been a part of on Earth. While the pages are full of grief at times, you’ll also find plenty of humorous moments throughout the captivating writing.

This is a great pick if you enjoyed Eliza Starts a Rumor, also by Jane L. Rosen, or Golden Girl by Elin Hilderbrand. Readers also enjoy the Jewish representation throughout.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Books With Characters In Their 30s

Not in My Book book cover

Book Summary

Rosie leaves her hometown in Tennessee and moves to New York City to pursue her dreams of being a writer. But things get off to a rocky start when she discovers that her arch-nemesis and ex-crush, Aiden, is in her writing workshop. Aiden may be gorgeous, but he’s also a surly and obnoxious literary writer with little patience for Rosie’s preferred romance genre.

Their constant classroom clashes prompt their professor to offer an ultimatum. If they want to stay in her class, they’ll have to co-author a manuscript that merges their opposing genres. The boundary between fiction and reality blurs as their work-in-progress provides an outlet for them to express their feelings of attraction.

When Rosie and Aiden again find themselves competing for a coveted career opportunity, their rivalry is reignited and threatens to unravel both their partnership and burgeoning romance.

The Book Girls Say…

This enemies-to-lovers novel set in the literary world is described as Beach Read meets The Hating Game.

This is Katie Holt’s debut novel. Readers especially love how she infused it with her Peruvian and Tennesseean heritage.

Story of My Life book cover

Book Summary

Hazel’s romance writing career has been stalled ever since a breakup left her with writer’s block. To make matters worse, she just lost her Upper East Side apartment, and her publisher is losing patience waiting for her next manuscript.

Facing an ultimatum – turn her book in by her next deadline or she’ll lose her publishing deal – she impulsively decides to relocate to a small town in Pennsylvania, hoping it will provide just the inspiration she needs. She buys a historic house sight unseen. After a less-than-smooth arrival in town (including a run-in with the local wildlife), she discovers that the house is dilapidated and the town is also on its last legs.

On the bright side, despite his grumpy demeanor, the contractor she hires to help renovate her house provides some swoon-worthy inspiration.

The Book Girls Say…

This book blends two of our favorite elements renovation romance and books about authors. Hazel’s writing process and her struggles to complete her manuscript play an important role in the plot.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 04/04/2025
Summer Fridays book cover

Book Summary

Sawyer is a twenty-something trying to make it in New York, working as an assistant for a publishing company. She’s engaged to her college boyfriend but is extremely lonely in the summer of 1999 as her fiancé keeps working longer and longer hours…with a female coworker named Kendra.

Kendra’s boyfriend, Nick, has the same concerns about the endless hours Kendra is spending at work with Sawyer’s fiancé. After a rough first meeting between Sawyer and Nick, they form a friendship via their AOL Instant Messanger chat. Soon, they start spending every Friday afternoon exploring the city together.

The Book Girls Say…

Reviewers praise the audiobook version of Summer Fridays. Readers who don’t enjoy this novel cite the cheating in the storyline as something they couldn’t get past, so if that’s also a dealbreaker for you, skip this one.

Readers have noted that the novel offers a nostalgic glimpse into the publishing industry of the late 1990s. Overall, the book is deeper than a typical romance and leaves plenty to think about.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Rom Com Books Set in New York

Verity book cover

Book Summary

Verity Crawford was a bestselling author of a popular series of books, but an injury has left her unable to complete the series. Her husband, Jeremy, hires struggling writer Lowen Ashleigh to complete his wife’s unfinished books. 

Lowen begins sifting through years of Verity’s notes and outlines, hoping to find enough material to work with. In the process, she uncovers Verity’s unfinished autobiography – one she doesn’t think Verity intended anyone to read. It’s filled with bone-chilling admissions – including the truth about what really happened the day Verity and Jeremy’s daughter died.

Lowen intends to keep her discovery of the autobiography manuscript secret in order to protect Jeremy. But as their relationship grows more complicated, she begins to reconsider. If Jeremy read Verity’s horrifying truths, could he continue to love his wife? And if not, would that make room for Lowen?

The Book Girls Say…

If you only like books with likable characters, then this may not be the title for you. By the end, you may not like any of them.

While many consider Colleen Hoover to be a YA author, this book is squarely an adult read because of numerous explicit scenes.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

19 Books Like We Were Liars

Summer I Found Myself book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

4.3 out of 5
100%
Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Ellen is an English professor going through a rough season of life. She’s newly divorced and not happy about it, and she’s lost her parents. It’s time for a reset, and she hopes to find some meaning by spending the summer at her parents’ Delaware beach house as she prepares it for sale. 

When her best friend, Lara, gets a cancer diagnosis, Ellen invites her to relax at the house as much as she can between chemo appointments. Supportive Lara hopes this time will let her assist Ellen in finding the best version of herself. Throughout the summer, Ellen grows with the help of Lara, a local writers’ group, and the new friends Lara meets during her treatment.

The Book Girls Say…

While this does have a romance thread, it’s more of a story of self-discovery and healing. Some readers are frustrated by Ellen’s initial unlikable characteristics, but once they remember she must have some redeeming qualities for the delightful Lara to be her friend, they sink into the book and really enjoy it.

Buried in a Book book cover

Book Summary

At 45, Lila is starting a new career as an intern at a literary agency after losing her job as a journalist. Being paid to read is her dream! Her new position is more difficult than she expects, with endless piles of query letters and some quirky co-workers.

Then, an aspiring author drops dead in the waiting room. Lila has an unexpected new task of uncovering a murderer after she finds a series of threatening letters. What is really going on at this thriving literary agency?

This is How it Always Is Book Cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

4.5 out of 5
100%
Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Claude is the youngest son in a family with five brothers. And he firmly knows that when he grows up, he wants to be a girl. His parents see his sincerity and opt to move out of their smaller town to Seattle, where they expect people to be more accepting of others. However, despite being okay with Claude being whoever he is, they don’t want themselves or Claude to be targeted as weird. In their new city, Claude is Poppy. The entire family keeps the secret until everything explodes one day.

The Book Girls Say…

This story is a timely look at the inner workings of a family with a transgender child. While the book is about a fictionalized family, the author has first-hand experiences with the topic, giving authenticity to the parents’ perspectives.

In this novel, the father is an author and his writing plays an important role in the story, making this a great crossover pick.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 10/04/2023
Summer of Yes book cover

Book Summary

Kelsey is a workaholic junior editor who dreams of being a writer. But she’s thriving in her comfort zone of helping other people tell stories. After an accident, she meets an older woman, Georgina, in the hospital. As Georgina faces her life regrets, Kelsey begins to consider her own list of “things I’ll do someday.” She wonders what would happen if she started saying “yes” to everything that is normally a no.

Kelsey convinces Georgina to join her on a Summer of Yes, whether this means an impractical convertible, dinner with strangers, or Kelsey’s surprise visit to Georgina’s son and ex-husband.

The Book Girls Say…

Some reviewers wish there was a stronger faith component, as the book was released by a Christian publisher.

By Any Other Name book cover

Book Summary

Despite Lanie’s successful career as a romance editor and a big promotion on the horizon, she has a difficult task to ensure her step up to editorial director. She must get the publisher’s biggest author, Noa Callaway, to turn in their manuscript, which is already 4 months late. That job seems impossible since no one even knows who Noa Callaway is. There is an NDA in place, no photos, and people don’t even know Noa’s gender. 

Because of the secrecy of Noa’s identity, part of the book is written in epistolary format via emails. That also makes it a slow-burn book, especially in the first half before the romance kicks in. 

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Rom Com Books Set in New York

April Crossover Books

The following books specifically satisfy this month’s Book Lover’s prompt, as well as a reading prompt for one of our other challenges:

*We’ve used asterisks below to note which challenge list the book originally appeared on

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

4.0 out of 5
92%
Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Lucy is a 26-year-old teacher’s aide hoping to adopt her student, seven-year-old Christopher. He tragically lost his parents, but she needs to be in a better financial situation for both the actual adoption process to be approved and to take care of Christopher long-term.

She’s always found comfort in books, especially the Clock Island series by Jack Masterson. The author stopped writing and became reclusive years ago, but she still regularly re-reads his work. Just when Lucy is about to give up on adopting Christopher, Jack Masterson re-emerges and announces a new book. However, it’s not a standard release. Four contestants will get to come to the real Clock Island and compete for a chance to win the single copy in existence, which is worth at least six figures.

The Book Girls Say…

This adventurous story is full of heart with a side of magic!

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

4.3 out of 5
98%
Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

When bombings began in London in 1939, 14-year-old Hazel and her 5-year-old sister, Flora, were evacuated to a rural village in the English countryside. Living with a woman and her teenage son in a charming stone cottage, Hazel comforts Flora by telling her stories of a magical fairy tale land. It provides the sisters with a fictional place where they can escape the fears and hardships of war. One day, while playing near the banks of the River Thames, Flora disappears. Hazel blames herself and carries the guilt into adulthood. Twenty years later, Hazel’s life looks ideal from the outside – charming boyfriend, a nice flat in London, and a good job at a rare bookstore. But on the eve of her new career at Sotheby’s, she unwraps a package that changes everything.

It’s an illustrated first-edition book called “Whisperwood and the River of Stars.” It’s the imaginary world that she created for Flora – one that she never wrote down and never told anyone else about. What does it mean? Is Flora still alive? And does this fairy tale hold the truth about her disappearance? Hazel embarks on a feverish quest for answers. Along the way, she’ll reconnect with people from her past and put her future in jeopardy.

The Book Girls Say…

Centered around the fairytale world created by Hazel for her sister, this novel blurs the lines between the real and the magical in the most wonderful way. The book focuses on the relationship between the sisters while also showing the realities of Operation Pied Piper and its long-lasting impacts on the families who were faced with such difficult choices during the war.

It’s hard to say too much without spoilers, but Angela loved the book from the first page to the last. Told in dual timelines, the mystery is unraveled bit by bit through beautiful prose.

Novel Love Story book cover

Book Summary

Literature professor Elsy loves to lose herself in a fictional happily ever after. She feels safest in the world of romance novels because those men never leave you at the altar.

When her car breaks down on her way to her annual book club retreat, she finds herself stranded in a quaint small town straight out of a book. Literally. Somehow, she seems to have ended up in Eloraton, the fictional town from her favorite romance series. Everything is perfect – from the candy store to the local bar and the afternoon rain.

The author passed away before finishing his last story in the Eloraton series, and Elsy is beginning to think it’s up to her to write the final happy ending. The only problem is the town’s grumpy bookstore owner. He’s the one character that Elsy doesn’t recognize from the series, and it seems that he doesn’t want Elsy to finish the book.

The Book Girls Say…

While Melissa didn’t rate A Novel Love Story quite as highly as much as Posten’s other work, The Dead Romantics, we couldn’t skip this fun read in which the main character literally becomes part of the story.

You Are Fatally Invited book cover

Book Summary

Renowned author J. R. Alastor has hired a former aspiring writer, Mila, to host a writing retreat at his private manor off the coast of Maine. She’s quickly on board because she’s upset at one of the six thriller authors on the guest list and welcomes the chance to confront them.

The retreat includes a week of games, driven by trope-filled riddles. But, when a real murder occurs, the authors find themselves entangled in a deadly plot that mirrors the suspenseful narratives they create, blurring the lines between their fictional works and reality.

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

4.2 out of 5
93%
Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Nora has decided she is done. Done with the way her life is going. In a moment of darkness, the 35-year-old attempts suicide, but she finds herself in the Midnight Library between life and death. The shelves go on and on, and inside each book is a life that she could have lived, had she made just one different choice somewhere along the way – from following dreams to pursuing different careers to undoing old breakups.

Each time she opens a book, she finds herself living that alternate life, and she is faced with the decision of whether she wants to permanently exchange her life for a new one. As she visits these alternate realities, she’ll have to decide not only which life she wants, but also what makes life worth living in the first place.

The Book Girls Say…

Some find this book to be too predictable – and it’s true that the synopsis of the book tells you exactly what to expect. However, this is a book that will really make you think – not just about Nora’s choices and regrets, but also about your own.

As mentioned, this book does deal with suicide contemplation. However, we believe by the end, you’ll be left positively contemplating life.

Close-Up Book cover

Book Summary

When Zoe moved to Los Angeles three years ago to pursue her writing career, she fell for Zach, an aspiring actor. He ended up ghosting her before he became famous. Sadly, like her relationship, her debut novel (a thriller) failed, and now she’s turning thirty and works at a flower shop.

When she makes a floral delivery one day, Zach answers the door. It’s instantly like they were never apart. When they quietly start dating again, her writer’s block disappears, and she hopes Zach can inspire her second novel like he did her first.

Instead, a photo of the couple is leaked and goes viral. This propels her original novel to success, and now everyone knows her name. Unfortunately, this includes a mysterious stalker obsessed with Zach…who begins reenacting violent events from Zoe’s book.

The Book Girls Say…

This thriller highlights the dark side of Hollywood fame, including drugs. It’s a slow-burn thriller with unlikable character, but readers who are okay with those aspects of a novel enjoy the creepy concept of Zoe’s thriller turning into her real life.

Ten Thousand Doors of January book cover

Book Summary

January Scaller is the ward of wealthy Mr. Locke. She lives in his sprawling mansion filled with artifacts and curiosities. Everything in the mansion is carefully maintained despite being largely ignored and utterly out of place.

Among the treasures, January finds a strange book. Within its pages, she discovers a tale of secret doors as well as love, adventure, and danger. With each turn of the pages, January discovers a story that seems to be increasingly entwined with her own.

The Book Girls Say…

This debut fantasy novel received more than a dozen book award nominations, and the audio version won an Audie award for Best Fantasy Novel. If you enjoy audiobooks, this could be a great pick.

Enigma of Room 622 book cover

Book Summary

Years ago, there was a murder in Room 622 of the Hôtel de Verbier, a luxury resort in the Swiss Alps. The murder was never solved.

Now, years later, a famous Swiss writer named Joël Dicker has arrived at the same hotel. He’s getting over a bad breakup, mourning the death of his longtime publisher, and he needs to begin his next novel. But before he knows it, he finds himself investigating the old cold case. Playing Watson to his Sherlock is the beautiful aspiring novelist in the room next door.

The Book Girls Say…

As you may have already noticed, Joël Dicker is both the author and the main character of this whodunit novel. He breaks the metaphorical “fourth wall” between the author and reader, directly addressing his audience and using his expertise as a thriller writer to investigate the murder mystery. What results is described by many as a multi-layer masterpiece—an unraveling of the story in the first-person perspective while, at the same time, Joël creates a full novel in the third person.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 01/14/2025

March Crossover Books

The following books specifically satisfy this month’s Book Lover’s prompt, as well as a reading prompt for one of our other challenges:

*We’ve used asterisks below to note which challenge list the book originally appeared on

Favorites book cover

Book Summary

Katarina didn’t have the family support or funding usually required to make it to the Olympics, but she knew becoming an Olympic figure skater was her destiny. When she has an instant connection with Heath, who was in the foster system, their chemistry and determination make them a formidable duo on the ice. Skating is the perfect escape from their difficult lives. The childhood sweethearts turn into crowd-favorite champions in the cut-throat world of ice dancing.

Their story takes a terrible turn after a shocking incident at the 2014 Winter Olympics in Sochi. Ten years later, an unauthorized documentary reignites the public obsession with Kat and Heath and promises to uncover the truth about their final skate. Kat initially wants nothing to do with the documentary, but more than that, she doesn’t want anyone else to tell her story. It’s finally time to share everything, and the truth may be even more shocking than her fans anticipate.

The Book Girls Say…

This 2025 release is receiving phenomenal reviews, with one calling it “beautifully brutal.” Others note that they were completely enamored by the tension that starts on page one.

The Middle Daughter book cover

Book Summary

This novel is a modern reimagining of the myth of Hades and Persophone set within a Nigerian family.

Nani is just 17 years old when she loses her older sister, followed soon after by her father. She doesn’t feel understood by her mother or her remaining sister, but she finds comfort in a handsome, itinerant preacher who offers her a new place to belong. It’s not long before she finds herself in an abusive marriage and estranged from her family. Will she be able to find the courage to break free without losing her children?

The Book Girls Say…

Nigerian-born author Chika Unigwe writes in both English and Dutch. She holds a BA in English Language and Literature from the University of Nigeria, Nsukka, an MA from the Catholic University of Leuven, Belgium, and a PhD from the University of Leiden, The Netherlands. She currently lives in Belgium with her husband and children.

NOTE: This book has dark themes throughout, so don’t pick it up looking for a lighter read based on the illustrated cover.

Beautiful Little Fools book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

96% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Revisit the glittering Jazz age with this atmospheric novel that reimagines The Great Gatsby from the perspective of three alternating female voices. When Jay Gatsby was found shot dead in his swimming pool in August of 1922, and a local mechanic was found dead in the woods nearby, the police viewed it as an open-and-shut case of murder/suicide. 

But then a diamond hairpin is found in the bushes around the pool, and three women suddenly become suspects – Daisy Buchanan, who once thought she’d marry Gatsby; Jordan Baker, who has a secret that could derail both her golf career and her friendship with Daisy; and Catherine McCoy, a suffragette who’s fighting for women’s rights and to protect her own sister from a terrible marriage.

This is a tale of money and power, marriage and friendship, love and desire, and ultimately murder.

The Book Girls Say…

Reviewers say this entertaining retelling of The Great Gatsby is perfect for fans of Big Little Lies.

Ayesha at Last book cover

Book Summary

Twenty-seven-year-old Ayesha lives with her boisterous Muslim family in Toronto and dreams of being a poet. For now, however, she needs her teaching job in order to pay off her debts to her wealthy uncle.

She’s lonely, and it doesn’t help that her family is constantly reminding her that her younger cousin has received closet to one hundred marriage proposals. Nonetheless, she doesn’t want an arranged marriage. Then she meets Khalid, who is the opposite of everything she thinks she’s looking for. Despite being handsome and smart, he’s also conservative, judgmental, and dresses like he’s straight out of the seventh century.

When a surprise engagement is announced between her cousin and Khalid, Ayesha is forced to confont her irritating attraction to him. Things are further complicated when she hears some unsettling new gossip about his family.

The Book Girls Say…

You might also like Uzma Jalaluddin’s Much Ado About Nada, which is a modern Muslim retelling of Jane Austen’s Persuasion.

This Motherless Land book cover

Book Summary

Funke had a happy childhood growing up in Nigeria with her art teacher mother, and professor father. But following a tragedy, she’s sent to England – a place she only knows from her mother’s stories. The much-lauded estate she’s heard so much about is now dilapidated, and both the weather and the food leave a lot to be desired.

The only member of her mother’s family that doesn’t act cold and distant is her free-spirited cousin, Liv. Filled with warmth and kindness, Liv helps Funke heal. As the two girls grow into women, they become close friends and Funke feels fiercely protective of Liv until another tragedy tears them apart.

In the shadow of their shared family history, each woman will struggle to find her way forward. Set in Lagos, Nigeria, and Somerset, England, over the course of two decades, the cousins – separated by country, misunderstanding, and ambition – will have to determine whether a family’s generational wrongs can ever be righted.

The Book Girls Say…

This novel has been described as Jane Austen meets Brit Bennett’s The Vanishing Half, and readers say it’s very enjoyable even if you are not familiar with Mansfield Park.

Author Nikki May was born in Bristol, England, and raised in Lagos, Nigeria, and is of Anglo-Nigerian descent. Her freshman novel, Wahala, received numerous accolades and is being adapted into a BBC TV drama series.

Wife Upstairs book cover

Book Summary

Twenty-three-year-old Jane is new to town. Working as a broke dog-walker in a fancy, gated neighborhood in Birmingham, Alabama, she can hide her real identity while lifting tchotchkes and jewelry right out from under the bored housewives who employ her without them even noticing.

But then she meets the most mysterious resident in Thornfield Estates. Eddie recently lost his wife, Bea, who drowned in a boating accident with her best friend. Jane doesn’t just see a grieving widower; she sees an opportunity. Eddie is rich and handsome and could offer her the protection she’s yearned for.

As Jane and Eddie begin to fall for one another, Jane feels increasingly haunted by the legacy of Bea. How can she live up to Eddie’s first wife with her rags-to-riches origin story and the wildly successful southern lifestyle brand that she built? And how long will Jane be able to hide her real identity?

This suspenseful novel is a twist on the Gothic classic Jane Eyre, which flips the script and shifts the power dynamic.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 02/03/2025
Emma of 83rd Street book cover

Book Summary

For 23 years, Emma has led a comfortable life on the Upper East Side of Manhattan. However, when she plays matchmaker for her sister, Margo, it results in a wedding, and Margo relocates downtown. Simultaneously, Emma’s friends seem to be traveling constantly, leaving her feeling bored and alone as her final year of graduate school looms.

Fortunately, she finds a potential new friend in Nadine, a newcomer to the city from Ohio. Emma is thrilled to give Nadine an NYC-style makeover as their friendship blossoms. Meanwhile, her childhood friend and neighbor, George Knightly, continues to dampen her spirits with his lectures on adulthood. Little does she know, this renewed attention from Knightly is because he can’t seem to get her off his mind.

The Book Girls Say…

This May 2023 release is a modern & spicy retelling of Jane Austen’s Emma.

Hours book cover

Book Summary

The Hours is a modern retelling of Virginia Woolf’s Mrs. Dalloway that incorporates Woolf as one of three characters in an overlapping story.

As you read, you’ll travel between Woolf in 1920s London, a mother in 1940s suburban LA trying to fit in time to read Mrs. Dalloway, and Clarissa Vaughan in 1990s Manhattan. Each character struggles to reconcile hope and despair in this moving novel.

The Book Girls Say…

This novel won the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction in 1999, amonth many other awards.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 02/04/2025
Black Woods, Blue Sky book cover

Book Summary

Life is tough for single-mom Birdie in her small Alaskan town where she brings her daughter with her to work at a roadside lodge. She’s getting by, but she misses the happier days of her youth when she roamed free in the wilds of nature.

Arthur is known as a recluse. Although he typically only appears in town during the change of the seasons, he brings Birdie’s daughter Emaleen back to safety when she gets lost in the woods. Even though most people avoid Arthur, Birdie finds herself falling for him and the wild land he inhabits.

Despite the warnings from those who car about them, Birdie decides that she and Emaleen will move into Arthur’s isolated mountain cabin. She envisions an idyllic, simple life off the grid, far from roads, telephones, and electricity. But she’ll soon discover that Arthur is something much more mysterious and dangerous than she ever imagined.

The Book Girls Say…

We really enjoyed Eowyn Ivey’s The Snow Child, and we can’t wait to once again visit the mythical landscapes of Alaska in her new novel that’s is a twist on Beauty and the Beast mixed with Alaskan mythology. While some have classified this book as fantasy, but others say it’s more accurately described as magical realism. And keep in mind that it’s darker than the Disney interpretation.

Beauty and the Beast was first written for adult readers in 1740 by Gabrille-Suzanne de Villeneuve, providing the backstory of Belle and the Beast and addressing issues related to the marriage systems of the time. In 1756, Jeanne-Marrie Leprince de Beaumont created a shortened version of the story aimed at younger readers, and it’s this version that forms the basis of the popular fairy tale we know today.

A Court of Thorns and Roses book cover

Book Summary

Feyre’s once wealthy family now lives in poverty and the 19-year-old hunts in the woods to provide for her family. One day she ventures deeper into the woods than normal and kills a wolf that she suspects might be a faerie in disguise. The following day, she’s confronted by a terrifying creature who demand retribution and drags her off to a treacherous magical land that she knows about only from legends.

In order to save her own life, Feyre agrees to live out the rest of her days in Prythian. As time goes on, her once icy feelings toward her captor, Tamlin, turn into a fiery passion. But something is not right in the faerie lands. An ancient, wicked shadow is looming, and Feyre must find a way to stop it, otherwise Tamlin – and the faerie world – will be doomed forever.

The Book Girls Say…

A Court of Thorns and Roses is considered a retelling Beauty and the Beast with elements of other folklore stories, including East of the Sun and West of the Moon and Tam Lin.

We know Romantasy isn’t for everyone (we haven’t gotten gotten into this genre ourselves), but A Court of Thorns and Roses has a high rating with more than 3.5 million readers on Goodreads, so we felt remiss leaving it off of the list. Since it’s the first in the series, it’s a good place to start if you want to try out this genre.

This series is generally considered a young adult novel, however it contains explicit sex scenes that make it better suited for mature readers.

Kiss Me Catalina book cover

Book Summary

Catalina “Cat” Capuleta is an ambitious singer living in San Antonio. When she is given the opportunity to join superstar heartthrob Patricio Galán on his seven-week Mariachi concert tour, she knows it’s the chance of a lifetime. Patricio might be a superstar heartthrob, but he also turns out to be demanding and arrogant. He challenges Cat at every turn, but she’s determined to make him feel he’s met his match.

Cat is also determined not to fall for him because her one and only goal is her own success so she can make her family proud. But when the duo hit the road, the chemistry is undeniable – even the audiences can feel it.

The Book Girls Say…

This modern retelling of Taming of the Shrew is a follow up to Oliveras’ previous novel (West Side Love Story) about Cat’s sister, but they read as stand-alones. Readers say they especially love the influsion of Mexican culture throught this novel.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 10/17/2024
Fairytale Life of Dorothy Gale book cover

Book Summary

Dee settled in Kansas to attend graduate school and live with her Uncle Henry and Aunt Em after her globe-trotting mother passed away. However, now she needs a quick escape after a humiliating public breakup with a faculty member, which felt like a tornado ripped apart her life. The Trinity College writing program is just the fresh start she needs!

In Ireland, she meets three new companions – seemingly brainless (but charming and hot) Sam Clery, heartless Tim Woodman, and fiercely loyal Reeti Kaur. With her new friends and the incredible women mentoring her in the writing program, Dee experiences a year of opportunities and changes. With everyone’s help, she’s ready to face her fears and apply all the lessons she has learned along the way.

Speak Easy, Speak Love book cover

Book Summary

This YA fiction set on Long Island in the Roaring Twenties is a jazz age retelling of Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing. After getting kicked out of boarding school, 17-year-old Beatrice goes to her uncle’s estate on Long Island, where her cousin runs a struggling speakeasy in the basement. Told from multiple points of view, this is the story of six teenagers whose lives intertwine during a summer of romantic misunderstandings and dangerous deals.

Described as “hilariously clever and utterly charming,” this YA novel set in the 1920s is filled with quick and hilarious banter that will keep readers of all ages turning the pages.

February Crossover Books

The following books specifically satisfy this month’s Book Lover’s prompt, as well as a reading prompt for one of our other challenges:

*We’ve used asterisks below to note which challenge list the book originally appeared on

Last Bookshop in London book cover

Book Summary

In 1939, Grace and her best friend, Liv, move to London and live with Grace’s late mother’s best friend, Mrs. Weatherford, and her son, Colin. While Grace isn’t a reader, she ends up with a job at Primrose Hill Books and works hard to clean and organize the messy store in hopes of earning the recommendation letter she needs to get the job she really wants at Harrods.

A customer named George helps Grace discover the magic of reading, and she’s soon hooked. Unfortunately, in 1940, the Blitz began, and daily life changed for every Londoner. While Grace continues her time at the bookshop, she also becomes an ARP (Air Raid Precautions) warden and is known for reading books aloud in tube stations during air raids. Will Primrose Hill Books survive this difficult period?

The Book Girls Say…

This novel is inspired by the true World War II history of the few bookshops to survive the Blitz. It’s said to be a great look into the life of brave Londoners during this tragic period at at the impact of war on average citizens.

While there are sad topics in the book, reviews say they appreciate that it manages to still be a heartwarming read with a good amount of focus on the bookstore.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 01/04/2025
Paris Bookshop for the Broken-Hearted book cover

Book Summary

Coco is having the worst month of her life. She lost her boyfriend and business, and she and her teen daughter had to move back in with her parents in Paris. Now, a handsome stranger is yelling at her under the Eiffel Tower!

Later that day, Coco discovers an old bookshop run by the mysterious Valerie. The store includes a café, cocktail bar, reading room, and even a secret tunnel of books. The store is intended to be a haven for the broken-hearted. It feels like a dream when Coco is offered a job as a bookseller in this magical shop. But then, she realizes that the grump who yelled at her earlier in the day is one of her new co-workers.

The Book Girls Say…

Reviewers compare the level of romance in this book to that of authors like Abby Jimenez, who put a lot of focus on the characters finding themselves outside of the relationship.

Storied Life of AJ Fikry book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

98% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Alice Island bookstore owner A.J. Fikry is having a terrible year. His wife has died, the store isn’t making enough sales, and his beloved book of Poe poems has been stolen. As a result, he’s cranky and pushing those around him away more than ever. Luckily he has a few people that look past his curmudgeonly attitude. 

His depression reaches the point that he no longer enjoys books. But, sometimes, life gives you second chances in unexpected ways. For A.J., it’s a small, but heavy, mysterious package that arrives at his shop. As he begins to see the world around him in a new way, those around him can see him in a new way, too.

The Book Girls Say…

This gem of a book is only 260 pages, so perfect if you’re short on time and still looking for an impactful read.

The Storied Life of AJ Fikry was also released as a movie. It would be fun to read with a friend and then watch together.

Bookshop Book book cover

Book Summary

In this 273-page non-fiction read, you’ll armchair travel to visit independent bookstores and their proprietors on six different continents.

From a tiny shop on a bike to a bookshop on a boat, you’ll fall in love with the quirky stores and their owners. Throughout the pages, you’ll also find lovely bookish quotes, interviews, and trivia.

The Book Girls Say…

This book is sure to inspire some new travel destinations for your bucket list! About half the book is set in the UK, with the remainder highlighting shops around the world.

If you enjoy humor writing, the author also has another non-fiction title, Weird Things Customers Say in Bookshops, that will make you laugh and roll your eyes at the funny things customers ask.

93% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Looking for an eerie mystery that’s perfect for book lovers? This highly-rated debut novel follows a bookshop employee named Lydia, who ends up investigating the suicide of one of her bookshop regulars.

As Lydia delves into his past, she also uncovers a buried memory from her own violent childhood. This twisty crime thriller with a very creative puzzle element that will keep readers guessing.

The Book Girls Say…

Colorado-based readers will recognize the Bright Ideas bookstore as The Tattered Cover. The author was a bookseller at this Denver book institution during the 1990s and used the store as his inspiration.

With Love, From London book cover
97% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

When Valentia was a teenager, her mother, Eloise, abandoned her and her father to start a new life in London. Now in her 30s, Val is a librarian and recently divorced. As she reevaluates her life, she realizes that the lack of closure with her mother is still nagging at her. But in a bittersweet twist of fate, Val learns that her mother has passed away before they’ve had a chance to reconcile.

Val is surprised to discover that Eloise left her a Primrose Hill apartment and the deed to a bookshop that Val never knew her mom owned. Determined to piece together a better understanding of Eloise’s life, Val decides to leave Seattle for a fresh start in London. It doesn’t take long for her to fall in love with the pastel-colored flat in a cozy neighborhood, not to mention the quaint bookstore. Unfortunately, she soon learns that The Book Garden is in financial trouble.

Told from a dual-timeline perspective, this book explores Valentia’s new life in London, as well as her mother’s past and what happened when she left her daughter behind.

The Book Girls Say…

Although the cover of this 2022 release says “sweet rom-com,” this is actually more of a feel-good story about mothers and daughters.

Sarah Jio also authored Goodnight June, another dual-timeline novel set in a Seattle bookstore. You’ll find that book on the recommendation list for a different prompt in the Book Lover’s Reading Challenge, but it would also make a good choice as a book about a bookstore.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Books with Characters In Their 30s

Forgotten Bookshop in Paris book cover

Book Summary

With WWII war closing in on their city, Jacques’ wife is forced into hiding. Desperate to hold onto something, Jacques focuses all of his effort on saving his beloved bookshop. But when a woman and her child show up at his door one night begging for refuge, he can’t say no.

In present-day Paris, Juliette and her husband are supposed to be on a romantic getaway, but instead, she quickly discovers how far they’ve grown apart. When she comes across an abandoned bookshop with a for-sale sign in the window, she thinks it might just be the new adventure she’s craving. But the bookstore hides a lot more than meets the eye.

The Book Girls Say…

If you’ve already read this novel and are looking for another WW2 Historical Fiction set in Paris that includes a bookshop, try The Paris Daughter by Kristin Harmel.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 01/07/2025

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

24 Best Books Set in Paris

The Bookshop Ladies blue book cover

Book Summary

Joy’s French husband has passed away, and she has no idea why he has left a valuable painting to a woman named Robyn on the western coast of Ireland. So, she decides to deliver the painting in person.

When she arrives in Ballycove, she finds that Robyn runs a chaotic and unprofitable bookshop and desperately needs assistance. Joy soon becomes entangled not only in the bookshop but also in the town. All the while, she’s still trying to discover the secrets behind her late husband’s painting.

The Book Girls Say…

While this book is not part of a series, if you’ve read other Faith Hogan books set in Ballycove, like The Ladies Midnight Swimming Club, you might recognize a few familiar faces.

Readers say this is a cozy, found family story despite having some heavier themes of grief.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 01/03/2025
An Irish Bookshop Murder book cover

Book Summary

Mercy and her twin-sister Lizzie are the new proprietors of an antique bookshop in the tiny Irish village of Shamrock Cove. However, their new venture takes a dark turn when Mercy finds their neighbor dying on his doorstep. Worse, he accuses her of murder before he dies, and several people hear him!

She has to quickly investigate to try and clear her name. As she looks through the victim’s old books, she finds that the local pub landlord, the kindly cook, and a neighborly knitter all had a reason to want the man dead. But, when Mercy’s top suspect also dies and leaves behind a threatening note typed on paper from Mercy’s new bookstore, things get even more complicated.

The Book Girls Say…

The additional books in this cozy mystery series also follow bookish storylines.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 01/04/2025
Bloomsbury Girls book cover
82% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Set in post-war London, Bloomsbury Girls focuses on an old-fashioned bookstore that has been run by men for a hundred years. However, by 1950, the world is changing in many ways. 

Three of the shop girls, Vivien, Grace, and Evie, have their own big dreams that are intersected by fascinating interactions with famous literary figures. As they work in the shop, they plot out a future bigger than 1950 society generally allows.

The Book Girls Say…

This is a slow-paced, character-driven read. It’s a great one to cozy up and learn about three strong women in post-war London, but keep in mind it does not have a page-turning plot.

While this is listed as the second book in the Jane Austen Society, it does work as a stand-alone read.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Books Set in the 1950s

Words in Deep Blue book cover

Book Summary

Childhood friends Rachel & Henry grew apart when Rachel moved, and Henry didn’t respond to a confession of her love that she left behind for him in a book.

Now, Rachel has moved back and is struggling with the death of her sister. She gets a job at the bookshop owned by Henry’s family, and is closed off to him as she still feels rejected. What she didn’t know is that Henry’s life is also going through a rough patch – his girlfriend broke up with him, and the bookshop is slipping away as his family breaks apart.

But as Rachel & Henry work together, they begin exchanging letters through the pages of books in the store. Can they find new hope in each other?

The Book Girls Say…

While the main character is experiencing grief in the book, reviewers say they still ultimately put the book down feeling uplifted.

Words in Deep Blue won many awards, including the Prime Minister’s Literary Award for Young Adult Fiction in 2017.

Borrow a Bookshop Holiday book cover

Book Summary

Jude is twenty-nine and just graduated, so she can finally be public about her relationship with philosophy professor, Mack. She’s looking forward to their upcoming dream holiday to run a tiny bookshop in the harbor village of Clove Lore.

Two weeks before the non-refundable trip, Jude sees Mack kissing someone else. Luckily, there’s no better place to heal a broken heart than a bookshop. Jude takes the trip and expects to have some peace alone at the store, but finds another vacationing shopkeeper, Elliot, who seems to be hiding something.

The Book Girls Say…

While this book is classified as a romance, some readers struggle with that aspect because they don’t find Jude to be overly likable. However, everyone seems to enjoy both the bookshop elements and the light mystery as you try to figure out Elliot’s past.

If the idea of trading in your life for two weeks to run a bookshop in coastal England is appealing, you’ll love this series! The fifth book, A New Chapter at the Borrow a Bookshop, has a publication date of 1/23/25, so if you’ve already read the first four books, you can pick up the new release for the challenge!

The Bookseller book cover

Book Summary

By day, Kitty is a single woman who owns a bookstore in Denver with her best friend, Frieda. In 1962, it was unconventional for a woman of her age to be an unmarried business owner, but she enjoyed having complete control over her day-to-day life without a husband to answer to. However, there was a man in her life once that she might have considered marrying—a doctor named Kevin.

But at night, Kitty leads an alternate life in her dreams. In this dream reality, Kitty goes by Katharyn, and the year is 1963. She’s married to the love of her life, a man named Lars. Together they live in an elegant Denver home and have triplets.

This life is everything that she once thought she wanted, and at first, Kitty enjoys her nightly visits to this alternate reality. But soon, Kitty begins to find Katharyn’s life irresistible. As the lines between her real life and her dream life begin to blur, she wonders if she can choose the life she wants – and if so, at what cost?

The Book Girls Say…

The Bookseller is set right in Book Girl Angela’s own little neighborhood in Denver! Locals will recognize Platt Park’s Old South Pearl Street during its cable car days and will enjoy stepping back in time to a decade when the University Hills were considered a southern suburb.

Cynthia Swanson also authored Anyone But Her, a dual-timeline novel that takes place in Denver in 1979 and 2004 and centers around a Colfax Avenue record shop owned by the mother of an East High School student.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

29 Fabulous Books Like The Midnight Library

The Rachel Incident Book Cover
92% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

University student Rachel works at a bookstore, where she meets James, who quickly becomes her new BFF and roommate. The duo runs the streets of Cork, striving for a Bohemian lifestyle but also sharply aware of a looming financial collapse.

When Rachel falls for her married professor, Dr. Fred Byrne, she plots to seduce him after a reading at her bookstore. However, Fred has other desires that launch a series of secrets and compromises that intertwine the fates of James, Rachel, Fred, and Fred’s glamorous, well-connected wife.

The Book Girls Say…

Reviewers say this book is spicy and provocative, so consider whether that is something you enjoy in your reading before selecting this one. It’s also a strong character-driven literary read with more subtle happenings than page-turning plot points. However, it’s a great pick for those interested in stepping into the life of a modern young woman in Ireland.

Born and raised in Cork, Ireland, author Caroline O’Donoghue now calls London home. Speaking about her hometown in an interview, she says, “Cork is goth. … It was like that when I was growing up, and it’s like that now.”

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Books Set in the 2000s

Paris Novel book cover
95% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

When her estranged mother passed away, Stella received a one-way ticket and a note reading, “Go to Paris.” While she is much more comfortable living within her strict routines, her boss encourages her to go on the trip.

In Paris, Stella continues to live as cautiously and frugally as she does at home until she stumbles upon a Dior dress in a vintage store. When the shopkeeper insists that it was meant for Stella, she impulsively purchases the dress and it launches a new outlook on life.

When Stella meets Jules, an octogenarian art collector, he takes her under his wing and shows her the best of the literary, art, and culinary worlds of 1980s Paris.

The Book Girls Say…

Both Book Girls read and enjoyed this character-driven novel. When Angela first started reading it, life was busy, and she was only getting in about 10 or 15 minutes at a time and found it hard to connect to the story, but as soon as she sat with the book for a longer chunk of time, she found herself drawn in.

This novel includes many of our favorite things – food, art history, fashion, and books (including interactions with real-life authors at the famous Shakespear and Company bookstore) – all set in the City of Light.

If you’re looking for more books set in Paris, be sure to check out these lists: Best Novels Set in Paris and Rom Com & Romance Books Set in Paris.

January Crossover Books

The following books specifically satisfy this month’s Book Lover’s prompt, as well as a reading prompt for one of our other challenges:

*We’ve used asterisks below to note which challenge list the book originally appeared on

How to Read a Book book cover

Book Summary

In Abbot Falls, Maine, three unlikely people are about to have their lives change after connecting at a bookstore. Violet is only twenty-two but was just released from prison after nearly two years due to a drunk-driving crash that killed a local kindergarten teacher. Harriet is a retired English teacher who runs a book club at the prison. And Frank is the handyman for a bookstore, and he had a complicated marriage to the woman Violet killed.

When Violet, Harriet, and Frank run into each other at the bookstore, they begin to learn about seizing second chances and the power of books to change our lives.

The Book Girls Say…

This book would also be a great pick when we get to the bookstore or book club prompts later in the year, but we chose to put it on this list because of the life-changing connections formed between the characters in this moving novel.

Book thief book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

94% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Liesel Meminger is a 9-year-old foster girl living in Nazi Germany in 1939. While trying to avoid all the death around her, she learns to read and begins stealing books. Soon, she’s sharing the books with neighbors and the Jewish man hidden in their basement.

It’s a heartbreaking read like so many others that cover this subject, but The Book Thief also underscores the vast power of books to help you through a terrible time.

The Book Girls Say…

Not only is Liesel using books to escape herself, as she shares them, she makes unexpected connections with neighbors.

Love at First Book book cover

Book Summary

Emily is a librarian on Martha’s Vineyard, but her desire for a more adventurous life leads her to Ireland. Her favorite author, Siobhan Riordan, has offered her a job helping her write the long-awaiting final novel in her series.

Things would be great if it wasn’t for Siobhan’s grumpy son, Kieran, who runs her bookstore. Tensions escalated with Kieran after Siobhan’s health declined. How can Emily help fulfill Siobhan’s desire to see her final book completed with Kieran?

The Book Girls Say…

Reviews say that while this book has a Hallmark-y plot on the surface, it also has emotional depth AND some steamy open-door scenes. Readers praise the descriptions of the Irish village, with many noting they wish it was a real place they could visit ASAP.

This highly-rated rom-com could fit several of our Book Lover’s prompts, including books about librarians, books about book stores, and books about writers. However, the heart of the story is two people connecting over their shared love of books.

NOTE: If you or someone close to you is going through breast cancer, it might not be the best time for this book.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Novels with Characters Connecting Through Books

People of the Book book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

93% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

In 1996, Hanna, a rare-book expert, is offered the job of a lifetime working on the conservation of the famed Sarajevo Haggadah, one of the earliest Jewish manuscripts ever illuminated with illustrations. The priceless book was rescued during the Bosnian War.
When Hanna discovers a series of tiny artifacts in the book’s ancient binding—an insect wing fragment, wine stains, salt crystals, a white hair—she begins to unlock the book’s mysteries.

Inspired by a true story, Pulitzer Prize-winning author Geraldine Brooks has created a novel of sweeping historical grandeur. In Bosnia during WWII, a Muslim risks his life to protect the book from the German army. In turn-of-the-century Vienna, the book has become a pawn in the struggle against the city’s rising anti-Semitism. In inquisition-era Venice, a Catholic priest saves the book from being burned. In Barcelona in 1492, the scribe who wrote the text sees his family destroyed by the agonies of enforced exile. And in Seville in 1480, the reason for the Haggadah’s extraordinary illuminations is finally disclosed.

WARNING: This book includes a scene of graphic rape.

The Book Girls Say…

Unlike the majority of the books on this list that directly connect two or more people, this novel shows the impact a single book can have over centuries. At times, this novel reads more like short stories of different people from different cultures in different time periods and how their lives were intertwined with the Sarajevo Haggadah.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Novels with Characters Connecting Through Books

Summer Hours at the Robbers Library book cover

Book Summary

Kit is the head librarian in the town of Riverton, New Hampshire, but for her, the library is more than just a job. It is a place of peace. When she’s there, no one expects her to talk about the calamitous events that have recently turned her settled, suburban life completely upside down. Instead, she can submerge herself in books and forget about her real-life problems for a while.

Kit’s quiet sanctuary changes suddenly, however, when a 15-year-old named Sunny is assigned community service at the library for the whole summer. Sunny was arrested for shoplifting a dictionary, and the judge threw the book at her, quite literally. Sunny is bright, curious, and eager to connect with someone other than the off-the-grid hippie parents who school her at home. She’s determined to coax Kit out of her self-imposed isolation.

Then there’s Rusty. He’s a Wall Street high-flyer who has recently crashed down to Earth. In this small town library, this unlikely trio is drawn together, along with a cast of other quirky regulars. They will be forced to examine how their lives have unraveled, but they’ll also help knit them together again.

The Book Girls Say…

While this book would certainly also fit on a list of books set in libraries, we were most intrigued by the connections formed by the unique cast of characters in the safe space of the local library.

This novel is described as a wry, observant look at life.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 11/09/2024

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Novels with Characters Connecting Through Books

Close-Up Book cover

Book Summary

When Zoe moved to Los Angeles three years ago to pursue her writing career, she fell for Zach, an aspiring actor. He ended up ghosting her before he became famous. Sadly, like her relationship, her debut novel (a thriller) failed, and now she’s turning thirty and works at a flower shop.

When she makes a floral delivery one day, Zach answers the door. It’s instantly like they were never apart. When they quietly start dating again, her writer’s block disappears, and she hopes Zach can inspire her second novel like he did her first.

Instead, a photo of the couple is leaked and goes viral. This propels her original novel to success, and now everyone knows her name. Unfortunately, this includes a mysterious stalker obsessed with Zach…who begins reenacting violent events from Zoe’s book.

The Book Girls Say…

This thriller highlights the dark side of Hollywood fame, including drugs. It’s a slow-burn thriller with unlikable character, but readers who are okay with those aspects of a novel enjoy the creepy concept of Zoe’s thriller turning into her real life.

If you are looking for the 2024 Reading Challenge Crossover list, you’ll find it here. This list identifies books that fit more than one of the monthly reading prompts, allowing you to count one book for two challenges.

FIND YOUR PERFECT BOOK LIST

Comments on: 2025 Reading Challenge Crossover Books

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *