Best Books from 2016

Whether you are participating in our In Case You Missed It Backlist Reading Challenge or simply found this post searching for the best books of 2016, you’ve come to the right place! Our list includes a mix of the best-selling novels of 2016 as well as highly-rated books published that year that flew a bit more under the radar.

three tilted book covers with Lilac Girls in the middle

There are so many great books released each year that it’s impossible to keep up. The Book Girls typically read about 200 books a year between the two of us, but nonetheless, our TBRs (to-be-read lists) just keep getting longer. And we know we’re not alone! With that in mind, we decided to take a look back at some of the best books that we missed from past years.

In Case You Missed It…

We’ve compiled a list of highly-rated books from 2016, including a wide variety of genres, from contemporary and literary fiction to mystery and romance. Our goal was to make these recommendations much more than just a list of the 2016 best-seller books. In addition to popular titles, you’ll find hidden gems that we think should have been more popular.

While researching 2016’s best books, we also had fun reminiscing about some pop culture moments that defined the year.

Five Things We Were Talking About in 2016

  • Television reboots are always hit and miss, but two in particular had everyone talking in 2016. Many fans were excited to return to Stars Hollow nine years after the finale of Gilmore Girls. Unfortunately, the four-episode Netflix miniseries revival, Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life, left many viewers very disappointed. On the other hand, Fuller House, the reboot of the iconic 1980s sitcom Full House, exceeded expectations by offering a slightly more grown-up version of its classic family-friendly cheesiness in a way that appealed to both existing fans and new audiences.
  • From her Super Bowl halftime performance to her genre-hopping Lemonade album, all eyes were on Beyoncé in 2016.
  • Nine years after the publication of the final book in the wildly popular Harry Potter series, fans were introduced to two new stories from the Wizarding World. In June of 2016, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child opened in London’s West End. The two-part play, which opened on Broadway the following year, is set 19 years after the Battle of Hogwarts and features adult Harry and his youngest son, Albus. Then in November of 2016, the film Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them opened in theaters. This story is set 65 years before Harry first attended Hogwarts, and follows a wizard tracking down lost magical creatures in NYC.
  • The July 2016 release of the Pokemon Go video game sparked a global phenomenon. This smartphone-based augmented reality game had cross-generational appeal and expanded the game into the real world, with players using GPS to track and catch virtual Pokemon around their own cities.
  • It’s hard to think back on 2016 without remembering the divisive presidential election. Kate McKinnon and Alec Baldwin’s impressions of the candidates on SNL gave us all something to look forward to and unite in laughter about each Saturday night, providing a needed break from the real news.

Best Books of 2016

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

97% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

What happens when a reclusive legendary author loses her money in a Ponzi scheme? She’s forced to write a book for the first time in decades, but her eccentric nature has the publisher concerned about their investment.

They send an assistant, Alice, to Mimi’s mansion to keep an eye on the writing progress, but Alice soon ends up spending more of her time with Frank, Mimi’s 9-year-old son.

Frank is witty, stylish, and not at all like the other kids in his school. Alice quickly appreciates his unique personality and becomes obsessed with finding out who Frank’s dad is…and whether family friend Xander is more than a friend.

The Book Girls Say…

If Elizabeth’s daughter, Mad, was your favorite character in Lessons in Chemisty, then we think you’ll enjoy Be Frank With Me! Like Mad, Frank doesn’t have much in common with the other kids at school. While these two children are unique in very different ways, both manage to steal the show.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 09/27/2023
Beartown Book Cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

96% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

In the tiny community of Beartown, life revolves around hockey. The sport provides entertainment and hope for a better future. This is a story about hockey, small-town life, and so much more.

When a shocking event occurs, the town quickly takes sides. Who will stand up for the truth and put hockey above humanity? From players and coaches to family members, wealthy sponsors, hooligans, and a bar owner, this entire tight-knit community is used to struggles, but this event challenges the town in a new way.

The Book Girls Say…

Fredrik Backman has a gift with words, melodic phrasing, and unparalleled insight into human motivations. He writes characters that are so well-rounded that even if you disagree with their decisions, you understand what they were thinking. We both gave this one all the stars!

Charm Bracelet book cover

Book Summary

It was a yearly birthday tradition for Lolly’s mother to give her a new charm for her bracelet, along with the familiar advice that there is nothing more important than keeping family memories alive. Those charms served as constant reminders of familial love.

Now, at the age of seventy, Lolly’s memory is beginning to fade and she desperately wants to reconnect with her daughter and granddaughter to share her family stories before it’s too late. When the two finally come home to visit her, the memories behind each charm on her bracelet will finally bring the three women closer to each other and also closer to finding joy, love, and faith.

The Book Girls Say…

Viola Shipman, the pen name for Wade Rouse, is one of our favorite authors of feel-good books.

Book Summary

Ted is 42 years old and struggling in his writing career and in relationships. His closest companion is his elderly dachshund, Lily. They do everything together. But now Lily has a new condition that Ted is having a hard time accepting.

This quirky novel turns into an adventure, which then spins into magical realism and beautifully written truths of loss and longing. It reminds us how it feels to love fiercely, how difficult it can be to let go, and how the fight for those we love is the greatest fight of all.

The Book Girls Say…

This is a really hard book to explain without spoilers. Melissa went into the novel only knowing it was written by one of her favorite authors, Steven Rowley, and it was about a man and his dog. And that is how this book should be enjoyed. It’s heart-warming, tear-jerking, and laughter-inducing. At some point, you will absolutely wonder what the heck is going on when magical realism makes an entrance. But just keep reading with your box of Kleenex close by.

Hating game book cover

Book Summary

Lucy and Josh are two colleagues who can’t stand each other. They work together at a publishing company, but their rivalry goes far beyond a typical work dynamic. They constantly compete for promotions and recognition, and their animosity is palpable. But when a promotion they both want becomes available, the game changes.

As they spend more time with each other, their feelings begin to shift. The hate they once felt transforms into something else entirely, and they’re left wondering if their animosity was really just a cover for something deeper. The plot is full of delightful twists and turns, keeping readers on their toes until the very end. It’s the perfect blend of humor, romance, and character development, making it a must-read for fans of the hate-to-love trope.

The Book Girls Say…

If you’ve enjoyed this book, don’t miss the movie, which is available on Amazon.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Books Like The Hating Game

Small Great Things

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

99% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Ruth Jefferson is a 44-year-old labor and delivery nurse with twenty years of experience at a Connecticut hospital. After being reassigned away from a patient, she learns that the parents are white supremacists and don’t want Ruth, who is African American, to touch their child.

The hospital complies with their request, but the next day, the baby goes into cardiac distress while Ruth is alone in the nursery. Does she obey the orders of her superiors based on the parent’s mandate, or does she intervene?

This story is told from three alternating points of view: Ruth, the nurse; Kennedy, her middle-aged attorney; and Turk, the newborn’s white supremacist father.

The Book Girls Say…

This novel is an emotional roller coaster ride that is painful to read at times, but we promise that it’s totally worth it. You may need to take a little break after reading the first chapter from Turk’s perspective, but after some deep breaths, please, please pick this book back up and keep reading. If we had the power, we’d make this book required reading for everyone!

A Gentleman in Moscow book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

95% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Count Alexander Rostov is sentenced to house arrest in the Metropol, a grand luxury hotel across the street from the Kremlin.

Deemed an unrepentant aristocrat, Rostov has never worked a day in his life and must now live in an attic room while some of the most tumultuous decades in Russian history unfold outside the hotel’s doors.

The Book Girls Say…

This one is high on our want-to-read list because the reviews all rave about the gorgeously descriptive language and the extremely satisfying ending. Don’t expect a fast-moving plot, A Gentleman in Moscow is more of a character study.

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

98% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Born a Crime is the true story of Daily Show host Trevor Noah’s childhood and early adulthood. His rise to success was unlikely based on his beginning. Trevor was born in South Africa in 1984 to a white father and a Black mother. His parents could have been imprisoned for five years – or worse – for conceiving him. He spent his early years largely hidden from life outside because his mother feared (with good reason) that he could be removed from her custody because of the apartheid rules of segregation.

When the era of white rule officially ended in the early 1990s, the family’s troubles evolved with the times. From attempted kidnappings and domestic violence to high school dating, you’ll find a mixture of relatable and shocking stories that keep you engaged with every page.

The Book Girls Say…

In true Trevor Noah fashion, you’ll be entertained while also receiving an education on life in apartheid South Africa. You will laugh and cry as you listen to him narrate his own poignant and honest stories.

We highly recommend listening to the audiobook, which Trevor narrates himself. Trevor speaks eight languages and draws upon each of them throughout the book to explain how languages can divide people, but can also be used to build bridges. We found it much more impactful to hear him speak each language with the correct sounds and pronunciations, rather than attempting our own phonetic reading.

There is also a young reader edition of Born a Crime; however, it’s not available in audio format.

Matchmakers of Minnow Bay book cover

Book Summary

Nothing in Lily’s life is going as she had planned. Her career hasn’t taken off yet, her boyfriend lets her down, she not sure she can trust her best friend, and she can no longer afford her apartment in the city. To make matters worse, she’s just been reminded that she failed to annul her quickie Vegas wedding… ten years ago!

It’s time for her to get her life together, and at the top of her to-do list is dealing with the fact that she’s still married. She knows this must be dealt with in person, so she sets off to track down Ben Hutchinson—the charming, sexy, and funny man that she connected with a decade earlier.

Ben’s life is much different than it was back then. He’s left his wealthy dot-com lifestyle behind and now lives off the grid in his small hometown of Minnow Bay, Wisconsin. The last thing he expects to upend his quiet life is a wife he didn’t even know existed.

For Lily, Minnow Bay could be everything she has been missing, including a thriving arts community, new friends, and maybe even the love of her life.

The Book Girls Say…

If you enjoyed other Kelly Harms titles, like The Overdue Life of Amy Byler, this may just be the perfect time to check out her backlist!

Behind Closed Doors book cover

Book Summary

To everyone who knows them, Jack and Grace appear to be the perfect newlywed couple. He’s a handsome and wealthy attorney who has never lost a case. She is an elegant and charming wife who keeps a perfect home and garden.

Together, they host elaborate dinner parties. But their guests begin to notice that Jack and Grace are inseparable—so much so that Grace is never available to meet for coffee or even answer the phone. And why does the house have such high-security metal shutters on all the downstairs windows?

The Book Girls Say…

This psychological thriller was nominated for two Goodreads Choice Awards in 2016 in the categories of Best Mystery & Thriller, as well as Best Debut Author.

Kindle Unlimited as of: 04/16/2024

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

98% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

When you think of maritime disasters, the Titanic is probably the first that comes to mind. But the deadliest disaster at sea occurred in 1945 when a Soviet submarine sunk the Wilhelm Gustloff, a German cruise liner, in the Baltic Sea.

As WWII drew to a close and the Red Army advanced on Germany, a massive evacuation effort began to ferry civilians, soldiers, and equipment to safety. The Wilhelm Gustloff, which had a capacity of 1,800, was packed with more than 10,500 passengers. More than 9,000 people lost their lives when the ship sank, including 5,000 infants and children.

This historical fiction YA novel, tells the stories of four passengers – 21-year-old Joana, who is fleeing her native country of Lithuania; Florian, an artist from East Prussia; 15-year-old Emilia from Poland, who is pregnant; and Alfred, a pompous 17-year-old German soldier.

When tragedy strikes, each of them – regardless of country, culture, or status – must fight for their survival.

The Book Girls Say…

One of our readers stated, “This book is so sad, so moving, and so well written. I enjoyed the fast flip between characters… it kept the story moving right along.”

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Books Set on a Form of Transportation

Book Summary

Cora is enslaved on a cotton plantation in Georgia, where she is an outcast even among her fellow Africans. With womanhood on the horizon, she knows that she’ll soon face even greater problems and pain unless she is able to escape to freedom. When she learns about the Underground Railroad, she decides to take the terrifying risk to escape. In this novel, however, the railroad is not merely a network of secret routes and safe houses. Instead, Colson Whitehead employs an element of magical realism. His Underground Railroad has engineers and conductors operating a secret network of tracks and tunnels beneath Southern soil.

Along the way, Cora kills a young white boy who tries to capture her. She is now being hunted as she continues to make her harrowing journey northward, state by state. She encounters different worlds at each stage of her journey, each created by the author to illustrate the unique terrors and dangers for African Americans in the pre-Civil War era.

The Book Girls Say…

This novel won the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction in 2017, as well as the Goodreads Choice Award for Best Historical Fiction in 2016. If you are interested in a nonfiction companion book about the Underground Railroad, we recommend Harriet Tubman: The Road to Freedom.

One True Loves book cover

Book Summary

In this story of love and loss, Emma married her high school sweetheart, Jesse. The two are building a life of adventure together on the West Coast, far from the expectations of their families back east. But on their first wedding anniversary, Jesse’s helicopter crashes over the Pacific Ocean and he is assumed dead. 

Just like that, the book closes on the fairy tale life that Emma thought would be her happily ever after. She moves back home to Massachusettes to rebuild her life. Years later, now in her thirties, Emma finally found love again after reuniting with an old friend, Sam. But when Jesse is found alive after more than four years, Emma will be forced to choose between her husband and her fiance.

Two-Family House book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

90% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Two babies are born during a blizzard in a two-family brownstone in Brooklyn. They arrive only two minutes apart, and the mothers, Rose and Helen, are sisters by marriage. Their spouses, Mort and Abe, are Jewish brothers who not only share the house but also own a business together. This moving family drama opens on that fateful night of the births in the late 1940s and spans the two following decades.


Over the years, cracks begin to form in the sisters-in-law’s relationship, and their friendship begins to unravel. The book is described as an “emotional but dreamy novel” that will have you sobbing and smiling.

Lilac Girls book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

100% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Lilac Girls crosses three continents and follows three women whose lives are on a collision course. 

Caroline is a New York socialite working at the French consulate, Kasia is a Polish teenager and a courier for the underground resistance movement, and Herta is an ambitious young German doctor who finds herself trapped in a male-dominated world of Nazi secrets and power.

The book alternates between the three stories, each providing thought-provoking insights into uniquely difficult situations as the war progressed.

The Book Girls Say…

Melissa loved Lilac Girls, although it includes tragic scenes that are tough to read. She was devastated when she learned that this historical fiction was based on the true experiences of the ‘Ravensbrück Rabbits.’

Get your tissues ready; this story is part of history that we shouldn’t ignore.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Books Set in the 1940s

It Ends with Us book cover

Book Summary

The book follows two significant periods in the life of Lily Bloom. As a teenager, she notices one of her classmates, Atlas, sleeping in the unoccupied house behind hers. When she begins sneaking him food, they develop a friendship that leads quickly to a deep first love. Lily’s life at home isn’t perfect, but everything feels right with Atlas. When they are separated, they vow to find each other again as adults.

Years later, on the day of Lily’s father’s funeral, she has a chance encounter with a gorgeous neurosurgeon, Ryle Kincaid. Despite Ryle’s complete aversion to relationships, he has a total soft spot for Lily. From the first time he sees her, he can’t get her out of his mind. Lily is busy trying to set up her own business, but when they run into each other again, she’s intrigued.

The Book Girls Say…

Sometimes you know a story is great when you’re so drawn into the characters that you passionately want to throw the book across the room while reading. We both had visceral reactions as we turned pages waiting to find out what choices Lily would make with her life. Then, when we got to the end and read the author’s note, we appreciated every page even more. 

One important note is that we think Colleen Hoover’s books work better as audiobooks. Some of the dialog and writing doesn’t seem as strong when physically reading, but then feel more natural when listening.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

20 Books Like It Ends With Us by Colleen Hoover

America's First Daughter book cover

Book Summary

Martha “Patsy” Jefferson was the oldest daughter of our founding father and eventual second president, Thomas Jefferson.

Patsy grew up knowing that her father loved her dearly, but sensing that he loved his country even more. After her mother died, Patsy became her father’s protector and constant companion, even traveling with him to Paris when he became the American minister to France. In Paris, during the early days of the Revolution, Patsy learns of her father’s liaison with a young enslaved girl named Sally Hemings, who is the same age as Patsy. Meanwhile, Patsy has fallen in love with her father’s protege and staunch abolitionist, William Short.

Torn between family loyalty, love, and her principles, can Patsy make a life as William’s wife while remaining a devoted daughter? The choices she makes will follow her back to Monticello in Virginia and even to the White House. Time and again, through scandals and tragedies, Pasty will be forced to decide how much she is willing to sacrifice to protect her father’s political legacy and that of the country he helped to found.

The Book Girls Say…

In writing this historical fiction novel, the author drew upon thousands of letters and original sources. This meticulous research brings to life the turbulent years after the Revolution in a way that we haven’t read before.

Mothers book cover

Book Summary

Nadia is a rebellious, grief-stricken, seventeen-year-old beauty in her senior year of high school. Luke is the pastor’s son in a contemporary black community in Southern California. He’s 21 and waiting tables after an injury sidelined his promising football career.

While Nadia and Luke’s relationship doesn’t start as a serious one, everything changes with a pregnancy and cover-up that follows them for years. The possibility of the road not chosen continues to haunt them into adulthood.

The Book Girls Say…

Before Brit Bennet found recognition and acclaim with her 2022 book Vanishing Half, she was nominated as Goodreads Choice Best Debut Author at only 25 years old for this 2016 release.

Woman in Cabin 10 book cover

Book Summary

Journalist Lo Blacklock scores a dream assignment when she’s sent aboard a super-luxury cruise ship, the Aurora, which only has a few cabins. As they set off across the North Sea, everything is perfect. However, as the weather becomes dreary, so does the mood on the ship when Lo witnesses a woman being thrown overboard. 

However, the crew confirms all passengers are accounted for and the vacation continues. Lo knows what she has seen and must get others to understand that something sinister has happened.  The book is often named one of the best modern locked-room mystery novels. 

The Book Girls Say…

If you liked The Woman in Cabin 10, try the author’s 2019 locked room mystery, The Turn of the Key.

Also Featured on These Book Lists:

Locked Room Mysteries

Behold the Dreamers Book Cover

Book Summary

When Jende and his wife Neni immigrate to the US from Cameroon, they expect to work hard but be rewarded for that work with a better life than they left behind. In 2007, he began working as a chauffeur for Clark, a Lehman Brothers executive who appears to have achieved the American Dream.

Jende is an exceptional employee, and his dedication leads to his wife’s job working for Clark’s family at their Hamptons house. With two incomes, the family can finally begin to see the possibility of their brave move to America paying off.

However, all is not as it seems with their employers. As they learn more secrets, the world is about to learn some secrets as well. Lehman Brothers is collapsing, and Jende’s job is no longer certain. He needs this job to get his permanent green card, so their entire future is at risk.

The Book Girls Say…

While this book feels very real, it is a work of fiction. The author was born and raised in Cameroon before receiving her undergraduate and graduate degrees in the US. She drew upon her observations of class divides in NYC, especially during the Great Recession, as the basis for Behold the Dreamers.

Serpent King book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

93% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

Dill’s father is a Pentecostal minister, who first drew attention for his extreme beliefs and then for a scandal. His friend Travis has his own demons in the form of an abusive father, so he escapes into a book series called Bloodfall. Dill has secret feelings for friend Lydia, a free spirit, sarcastic, fashion blogger who dreams of leaving rural Tennessee and heading to New York. 

Woven into this story of three unlikely friends trying to navigate the end of high school are stories of small-town life and themes of courage. But you’ll also need a box of tissues handy! 

The Last Days of Night book cover

Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book

100% Would Recommend to a Friend

Book Summary

In 1888 New York, the streets were still lit by gas lamps, but the promise of the light bulb looms. However, the switch to electric light came with an additional complication – both George Westinghouse and Thomas Edison claimed to have invented the lightbulb.

A young lawyer, Paul Cravath, is thrust into the world of New York high society when he agrees to defend Westinghouse in a lawsuit brought by Thomas Edison. Edison has spies and vast resources, including the backing of J.P. Morgan. How can they fight against such a force?

When Paul meets Nikola Tesla, he may have found the secret to defeating Edison. But winning requires risks.

The Book Girls Say…

The Last Days of Night was a Goodreads Choice Award Nominee for Historical Fiction in 2016. It has been a favorite among readers who pick it up as part of our Decades Reading Challenge.

Dark Matter book cover

Book Summary

Jason is walking home one chilly night, looking forward to relaxing in front of the fireplace with his wife and son. Suddenly, he hears “Are you happy with your life?” before being knocked unconscious.

When he wakes up, he’s surrounded by strangers in Hazmat suits. His life is no longer his own. His wife is different, he doesn’t have a son, and instead of being a professor, he’s a celebrated genius.

Which is his real world, and which is a dream? And how can he return to his son?

The Book Girls Say…

Dark Matter was a 2016 Nominee for Best Science Fiction. Author Blake Crouch also wrote the popular Wayward Pines trilogy.

You are welcome to choose any book you’d like to read for the challenge, but we hope this list of books has given you a good starting point.

Sign Up for the ICYMI Backlist Challenge

Sign up for our email list below to receive a free printable tracker for the In Case You Missed It Backlist Challenge. Our weekly email newsletter helps you stay on track with friendly reminders while still allowing you the flexibility to read at your own pace. Additionally, challenge participants have an opportunity to discuss the books on this list and to provide ratings and reviews via our book logs.

Printable Version of This Book List

Readers who support The Book Girls’ Guide through our Buy Me a Coffee (BMAC) membership site have access to two different printable versions of this book list.

New for 2024, members can print a single page containing all the book titles from each guided challenge list. We will also continue providing the journal page format, which has space to indicate your interest level in each book, jot down notes, and rate the books once you have read them.

Two printable options of this book list

Our BMAC members (we call them our BFFs) help cover the cost of running the challenges so we can keep them free for everyone. You can read more about why our members are essential and learn about the perks of membership.

FIND YOUR PERFECT BOOK LIST

Comments on: Best Books from 2016

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *