SIGN UP! 
The Best Kindle Unlimited Romance Books with Fall Vibes
By: Angela & Melissa
Updated:
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, we may earn a referral fee from qualifying purchases.Both of us Book Girls have been Kindle Unlimited subscribers for several years now, and one of our favorite parts of the membership is the great selection of romance books. We read a wide variety of genres each month, but there’s nothing better than a good rom-com between heavier books.
When it comes to reading romance, we especially enjoy seasonal books. With that in mind, we compiled a list of some of the best, highly-rated Kindle Unlimited romance books for fall.
If you’re not yet a member but you’ve been considering joining Kindle Unlimited, we have a helpful post that breaks down all the pros and cons.
Highly Rated Fall Romance Books on Kindle Unlimited
It’s Different This Time
Book Summary
Five years ago, June and Adam were best friends sharing a brownstone in NYC. Since that time, almost everything has changed. June and Adam are no longer friends, and June chased her dreams to LA, where she landed a hit TV show.
Right after learning that her show is being canceled, June receives a cryptic email from the company that manages the brownstone. With nothing to lose, she decides to fly back to NYC.
It turns out that, thanks to a legal loophole, if June and Adam move back into their beloved West Village brownstone together for one month, it will become theirs. Any New Yorker knows that you don’t pass up prime real estate.
Fall in NYC is the most magical time of year, but is it enough to bring these two former friends back together?
The False Flat
Book Summary
Thirty-two-year-old Penelope has had enough of her overbearing mother, her married boyfriend, and her sexist boss. Her life needs a reset, so Pen picks up and moves from Minnesota to Tennessee to open her own financial business.
Once in Nashville, Pen meets brother and sister, Deanna and Grant. Despite the siblings’ best efforts, socially anxious Pen is reluctant to come out of her shell. She slowly opens up to a friendship with Deanna, and after joining Grant’s cycling group, it’s clear that something is blossoming between the two of them. But Pen is determined to ignore her feelings for Grant.
The Book Girls Say…
The title of this book is a metaphor for Pen’s life. In the cycling world, a “false flat” refers to a road that appears delightfully flat and straightforward, but is actually a consistent low-grade climb that wears a rider out.
Early readers praise the character development and say this is not your typical light romance. This book also includes themes of anxiety and trauma, as well as found-family.
Pumpkin Everything
Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book
Book Summary
Amy Fox is a horror novelist with a major case of writer’s block. She’s heartbroken after recently calling off her fall wedding.
When she receives a call that her grandfather broke his wrist driving through a Dunkin’ Donuts (literally right through the front of the store), she has to return to her hometown of Autumnboro, New Hampshire, to care for him. But returning home runs the risk of bumping into Kit Parker – her childhood best friend and first love.
The Book Girls Say…
This book is light and sugary sweet, but it will transport you to small-town New Hampshire. If you’re looking for a quick and cute romance, this book fits the bill. True to a Hallmark-style romance, this book is a clean read. In fact, this book was adapted into a Hallmark movie in the fall of 2022, although the plot of the movie bears little resemblance to the book.
If you enjoy Pumpkin Everything, you can continue to enjoy the New England autumn via the sequel, Maple Sugar Crush.
Let’s Give ‘Em Pumpkin to Talk About
Book Summary
Textile artist Sadie Fox came home to Indiana for one reason, and one reason only – to care for her father’s beloved pumpkin patch and grow a pumpkin big enough to win the Indiana State Fair in order to win back her father’s respect.
Unfortunately, things are not going according to plan. A horde of wild hogs destroyed the entire pumpkin patch. And to make matters worse, the annoyingly sexy next-door neighbor, Josh, is offering help, despite being her biggest competition.
Josh is a tech millionaire who traded in the office for growing gourds, and he and Sadie couldn’t be more different. He’s all sunshine, while she’s tattoos, swear words, and a prickly personality. But nonetheless, there’s definitely something growing between them – something bigger than their pumpkins, or the secret Josh is hiding.
The Book Girls Say…
Readers say this is a perfect mix of cozy and spicy, perfect for pumpkin season.
Book Summary
Julia thought her future was in the Italian B&B she was going to restore with her boyfriend, Luca. However, they broke up a year ago and still live together in the dilapidated B&B. She’s broke, and her passport has expired.
She has to make some money in order to afford a flight home to Australia, and she knows she needs to get away from Luca in order to move forward in life. A job on an olive farm in Cividale del Friuli, the ancient Italian town on the banks of the gloriously blue Natisone River seems like the perfect escape.
Julie has her walls up when she arrives, but then the community of farmers, neighbours and locals generously welcome her into their lives. One of the locals, the broodingly handsome Alex, has also sworn off love for his own reasons, but maybe they need each other.
The Book Girls Say…
Readers say that while this novel includes a sweet romance with a little spice, it also includes some seriousness and grief as a good balance. Dog-lovers will enjoy Julie’s exuberant pup, Arco, more than Attila, Alex’s Persian cat does.
The Make Up
Book Summary
Chloe and Hunter have been friends since high school. When he invites her to co-star alongside him as the lead love interest in a country music video that he’s directing, she knows it will be an acting challenge.
She’ll have to act like she’s in love with Hunter without giving away the fact that she actually is. This is made all the harder when the full force of his charm is being directed at her.
The Book Girls Say…
This laugh-out-loud rom com is a clean read with sizzling chemistry, but nothing more than kissing on page. You’ll see Chloe and Hunter’s relationship both in the past and the present in alternating chapters. The present-day timeline has the perfect cozy, fall vibes.
While it’s listed as the second book in the Falling for Franklin series, the author says that the books read as standalones and can be enjoyed in any order.
Just Don’t Fall
Book Summary
As a teenager, Parker fell hard for her brother’s best friend, Logan, but he ghosted her and broke her heart. Logan went on to become hockey’s hottest bad boy, but now an injury has forced him to return to Harvest Hollow to play for his hometown’s minor league team. Parker is the team’s social media manager, so it’s her job to convince Logan to cooperate with the filming of trending TikTok videos.
Parker’s dad is trying to match her up with his business partner’s son. To avoid the setup, Parker ends up fake-dating Logan. The problem is that Parker’s old crush on Logan has resurfaced, and the feelings she’s supposed to be faking are starting to feel a bit too real.
The Book Girls Say…
This closed-door, small-town, hockey rom-com is perfect for those looking for a clean read. While most hockey romance books are quite spicy, Just Don’t Fall delivers all the chemistry without the spice.
This is the first title in the seven-book Sweater Weather series. Each book in the series is written by a different author, but all are set in the same fictional small town of Harvest Hollow. Each book reads as a standalone, so they can be read in any order. All are currently available with Kindle Unlimited.
Coming Home to Starr’s Fall
Book Summary
Starr’s Fall is a town in need of a fresh start, and Laurie is a woman who needs the same. She and her dog, Max, are new in town, and she hopes that reopening one of the empty shops on the main street will give her a fresh start.
The grumpy bookstore owner across the street, Joshua, should be happy that another shop is opening, but he thinks Laurie’s idea of a dog bakery and pet shop is ridiculous. But Laurie is undeterred. She also has a secret mission in town that involves a tragedy in her past.
The Book Girls Say…
This book is tagged as a clean romance, so it’s perfect if you prefer your romance more Hallmark-style with less spice. While this is a feel-good read overall, it does include some depth and harder topics, including grief and growing up in the foster system.
While this novel is set in the autumn, there is also second book set in Starr’s Fall that is full of spring vibes!
Book Summary
If college football is your preferred fall sport, you might enjoy this slow-burning romance about Dylan, a star wide receiver expected to be drafted into the NFL. He meets quirky classmate Zoe during an embarrassing encounter and then runs into her again and again. Prepare to experience second-hand embarrassment for Zoe!
The Book Girls Say…
The story unfolds from the alternating points of view of Dylan and Zoe. Through the book, you’ll see them turn from strangers to accidental roommates, from friends to best friends, and from best friends to much more.
The Modern Girl’s Guide to Magic
Book Summary
Aria comes from a family of witches, but her magic always manages to blow up in her face. That’s why she left the magical village of Charming Cove to work a regular job in London. But her wonky magic still seems to get in her way.
After losing her job, her grandmother insists that she compete in a competition to win the biggest magical fortune in England, the Garden of Enchantment. Aria wants nothing to do with the competition, especially when she learns that her nemesis, Callan, is also a competitor. But when she learns that winning is the only way to save her grandmother’s potion shop, she finally gives in.
The Book Girls Say…
This magical enemies-to-lovers romantic comedy is perfect for the fall season. The sequel, How to Fake-Date a Vampire has a publication date of August 31, 2023.
Autumn Getaway
Book Summary
Lydia is recently divorced and looking forward to attending her college roommate’s wedding. It will be a much-needed fall getaway with old friends to a beautiful manor in Connecticut. She never expected to meet a man, but she can’t help feeling an instant connection with Sam, a friend of the groom.
Lydia isn’t sure she’s ready for a new relationship so soon, but her friends encourage her to give Sam a chance. When the weekend comes to an end, and they each head their separate ways – him to Chicago and her to NY – will the spark survive the distance?
The Book Girls Say…
This is not a stereotypical “insta-love” story. It’s a refreshing slow burn where the characters like each other enough that they want to get to know each other more.
We tend to like heavier novels in the fall, but sometimes you just need a soft and cozy book with fall vibes between the more intense, emotional reads. Reviewers say that reading this book “is like being wrapped in your favorite blanket with a warm cup of coffee.”
This title is the first in a series of four, each set in a different season.
A Pumpkin and a Patch
Book Summary
Josie has written many cute children’s stories set on her family’s pumpkin farm. But unfortunately, the only story anyone seems to remember is the one she wishes they would forget. As a teenager, she penned a fantasy romance in which she cast herself opposite an older guy at school that she had a crush on. To this day, she is known around town as the “Reece the Rogue Pirate” girl.
The real-life Reece grew up to be a lawyer, and he’s now representing Josie’s ex-fiancé in a legal battle over the engagement ring. To complicate matters even further, Reece also has an adorable daughter, and Josie is her teacher.
The Book Girls Say…
Readers describe this book as adorable and charming, with likable characters and major fall vibes.
This is a clean, closed-door romance perfect for fans of Hallmark movies and the single dad trope.
Pumpkin Spice and Not So Nice
Book Summary
Jenna’s toxic trait is that she’s constantly attracted to the wrong men – ones who are totally emotionally unavailable. She wants to change them, and she’s objectively good at it. She can turn any dysfunctional man into Prince Charming, but unfortunately, they all go on to marry the next woman they meet instead of Jenna.
When she finds a fifty-dollar bill with a handwritten note on it that was accidentally donated to her family’s pumpkin patch, it turns out that the mystery man it belongs to is extremely attractive. But it should come as no surprise to Jenna that he’s also emotionally unavailable. She knows that this time she should just walk away, but when sparks fly, she tries to convince herself that this time will be different.
The Book Girls Say…
This is a companion book to A Pumpkin and a Patch. Though written by two different authors, the main characters in each book are fictional cousins, and the stories surround the same small town pumpkin patch. Though each book reads as a standalone, if you do read both, you’ll enjoy the overlapping characters in the town.
This is a slow-burn romance that is far more sweet than spicy, and is perfect for fans of small-town romances and the grumpy/sunshine trope. Just be sure to read the tips for dating emotionally unavailable men as humor and not as actual life advice.
Book Summary
While Emily dreams of making a living as an artist, at 35, she’s still working at her grandmother’s Vermont inn. She tends to play it safe and is the only one in her friend group who hasn’t tried to summit the mountain in their hometown of Crescent Falls, Vermont.
Diana is a go-getter and so close to being next in line as CEO of her father’s hotel chain. Everything in her life is following her careful plans…until she meets an alluring artist on a Vermont mountain.
Emily and Diana’s passion for each other grows quickly…until they realize that Diana is in town to buy Emily’s grandmother’s beloved inn.
Falling Inn Love
Book Summary
After tragically losing her family, Beth has been struggling to find her way. As a romance author, her writing is the only place she can find a bit of peace.
When she winds up stranded on the side of the road in Freedom Valley, New Hampshire, a local innkeeper comes to her rescue. And he is a very attractive, green-eyed, bearded, flannel-wearing innkeeper, no less.
Evan is a former Marine struggling to keep his family’s inn afloat after the sudden loss of his family. Beth agrees to help him run the inn for a short time, in exchange for room and board. Evan hopes she’ll stay longer.
The more Evan tries to get her to let her guard down, the more walls she builds up around her. But he’s willing to use any trick in the book to make her want to stay – including the adorable puppies he rescues from the side of the road.
The Book Girls Say…
This book reads like a fall Hallmark movie, and the cast of supporting characters in the small town gives Stars Hollow vibes (if you know, you know). It’s a cozy and sweet rom com, but it doesn’t shy away from the hard issues.
While it’s the first in a series, the book reads as a complete standalone. However, if you choose to keep reading after this first book, the characters and families in the other books are interconnected.
Red, White, and Royal Blue
Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book
Book Summary
Alex is the early 20-something son of the first female US President, and Prince Henry is the 2nd in line to the British Throne. Alex considers Henry his nemesis, and the two get into an embarrassing scuffle during a royal wedding.
In order to calm the press and convince them the sons of the US and England aren’t foes, Alex and Henry agree to make public appearances as friends over the course of several months. After spending more time together, and exchanging many amusing text messages, Alex realizes there is much more to Henry than he assumed.
The Book Girls Say…
After reading this fall election session romance, cozy up with your pumpkin spice latte and check out the highly-rated movie adaptation by the same name!
In Her Pumpkin Patch
Book Summary
Cheerful Penny loves pumpkin spice and everything else about fall too, with Halloween being her absolute favorite. Her hometown of Harrogate is the original Halloween town. She should be thrilled to be returning home, but she can’t get over the sense of failure that she’s only coming back because her journalism career in Manhattan didn’t work out.
Billionaire Garrett despises pumpkins, Halloween, and the overwhelming sense of dread as the cold and damp move in. When his new chauffeur arrives for her first day, she’s driving a hearse with Halloween carols booming.
The Book Girls Say…
This grumpy-meets-sunshine billionaire romance is perfect for those looking for an EXTRA steamy Halloween rom com this fall. Some reviewers think this novel was a bit long and would have been better in a novella length, so don’t pick it up if you’re looking for a speedy read.
More Book Lists Featuring Kindle Unlimited Titles
