2025 Reading Challenge Crossover Books
If you’re participating in our 2025 Book Lover’s Challenge, this crossover list highlights the books that fit the monthly Book Lovers prompt AND one of the monthly prompts for our other yearlong reading challenges. We hope this helps during those months that you need to double-dip and provides a quick shortcut to stay on track with the challenges even when life gets busy.
If you are looking for the 2024 Reading Challenge Crossover list, you’ll find it here. This list identifies books that fit more than one of the monthly reading prompts, allowing you to count one book for two challenges.
We will update this page each month after curating the recommended reading list for the Book Lover’s Challenge, and you’ll always find the most recent month at the top of the page. Use the table of contents above if you’d like to jump directly to a specific past month.
We initially planned to identify all crossover books for the various challenges, but with six total yearlong challenges, there are 15 different combinations possible each month. Not only does it feel overwhelming for us to check for all potential crossovers each month, but it also feels like the resulting list would be overwhelming and confusing for you. However, you are always welcome to count any crossovers you find between the existing challenges.
January Crossover Books
The following books specifically satisfy this month’s Book Lover’s prompt, as well as a reading prompt for one of our other challenges:
- Book Lover’s Challenge – Characters Connecting Through Books
- In Case You Missed It (ICYMI) – Books Published in 2013
- Read Around the USA – Books Set in MA, ME, NH, RI, VT
- Decades Challenge – Books Set in the 1880s and 1890s
- Book Voyage – Books Set in the Arctic & Antarctica
- Lifetime – Books with a Child Protagonist
*We’ve used asterisks below to note which challenge list the book originally appeared on
How to Read a Book
Book Summary
In Abbot Falls, Maine, three unlikely people are about to have their lives change after connecting at a bookstore. Violet is only twenty-two but was just released from prison after nearly two years due to a drunk-driving crash that killed a local kindergarten teacher. Harriet is a retired English teacher who runs a book club at the prison. And Frank is the handyman for a bookstore, and he had a complicated marriage to the woman Violet killed.
When Violet, Harriet, and Frank run into each other at the bookstore, they begin to learn about seizing second chances and the power of books to change our lives.
The Book Girls Say…
This book would also be a great pick when we get to the bookstore or book club prompts later in the year, but we chose to put it on this list because of the life-changing connections formed between the characters in this moving novel.
Also Featured on These Book Lists:
Maine Books: The Best Books Set in the Pine Tree State
Novels with Characters Connecting Through Books
The Book Thief
Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book
Book Summary
Liesel Meminger is a 9-year-old foster girl living in Nazi Germany in 1939. While trying to avoid all the death around her, she learns to read and begins stealing books. Soon, she’s sharing the books with neighbors and the Jewish man hidden in their basement.
It’s a heartbreaking read like so many others that cover this subject, but The Book Thief also underscores the vast power of books to help you through a terrible time.
The Book Girls Say…
Not only is Liesel using books to escape herself, as she shares them, she makes unexpected connections with neighbors.
Love at First Book
Book Summary
Emily is a librarian on Martha’s Vineyard, but her desire for a more adventurous life leads her to Ireland. Her favorite author, Siobhan Riordan, has offered her a job helping her write the long-awaiting final novel in her series.
Things would be great if it wasn’t for Siobhan’s grumpy son, Kieran, who runs her bookstore. Tensions escalated with Kieran after Siobhan’s health declined. How can Emily help fulfill Siobhan’s desire to see her final book completed with Kieran?
The Book Girls Say…
Reviews say that while this book has a Hallmark-y plot on the surface, it also has emotional depth AND some steamy open-door scenes. Readers praise the descriptions of the Irish village, with many noting they wish it was a real place they could visit ASAP.
This highly-rated rom-com could fit several of our Book Lover’s prompts, including books about librarians, books about book stores, and books about writers. However, the heart of the story is two people connecting over their shared love of books.
NOTE: If you or someone close to you is going through breast cancer, it might not be the best time for this book.
Also Featured on These Book Lists:
People of the Book
Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book
Book Summary
In 1996, Hanna, a rare-book expert, is offered the job of a lifetime working on the conservation of the famed Sarajevo Haggadah, one of the earliest Jewish manuscripts ever illuminated with illustrations. The priceless book was rescued during the Bosnian War.
When Hanna discovers a series of tiny artifacts in the book’s ancient binding—an insect wing fragment, wine stains, salt crystals, a white hair—she begins to unlock the book’s mysteries.
Inspired by a true story, Pulitzer Prize-winning author Geraldine Brooks has created a novel of sweeping historical grandeur. In Bosnia during WWII, a Muslim risks his life to protect the book from the German army. In turn-of-the-century Vienna, the book has become a pawn in the struggle against the city’s rising anti-Semitism. In inquisition-era Venice, a Catholic priest saves the book from being burned. In Barcelona in 1492, the scribe who wrote the text sees his family destroyed by the agonies of enforced exile. And in Seville in 1480, the reason for the Haggadah’s extraordinary illuminations is finally disclosed.
WARNING: This book includes a scene of graphic rape.
The Book Girls Say…
Unlike the majority of the books on this list that directly connect two or more people, this novel shows the impact a single book can have over centuries. At times, this novel reads more like short stories of different people from different cultures in different time periods and how their lives were intertwined with the Sarajevo Haggadah.
Also Featured on These Book Lists:
Summer Hours at the Robbers Library
Book Summary
Kit is the head librarian in the town of Riverton, New Hampshire, but for her, the library is more than just a job. It is a place of peace. When she’s there, no one expects her to talk about the calamitous events that have recently turned her settled, suburban life completely upside down. Instead, she can submerge herself in books and forget about her real-life problems for a while.
Kit’s quiet sanctuary changes suddenly, however, when a 15-year-old named Sunny is assigned community service at the library for the whole summer. Sunny was arrested for shoplifting a dictionary, and the judge threw the book at her, quite literally. Sunny is bright, curious, and eager to connect with someone other than the off-the-grid hippie parents who school her at home. She’s determined to coax Kit out of her self-imposed isolation.
Then there’s Rusty. He’s a Wall Street high-flyer who has recently crashed down to Earth. In this small town library, this unlikely trio is drawn together, along with a cast of other quirky regulars. They will be forced to examine how their lives have unraveled, but they’ll also help knit them together again.
The Book Girls Say…
While this book would certainly also fit on a list of books set in libraries, we were most intrigued by the connections formed by the unique cast of characters in the safe space of the local library.
This novel is described as a wry, observant look at life.
Also Featured on These Book Lists:
February Crossover Books
The following books specifically satisfy this month’s Book Lover’s prompt, as well as a reading prompt for one of our other challenges:
- Book Lover’s Challenge – Books Set in Bookstores
- In Case You Missed It (ICYMI) – Books Published in 2014
- Read Around the USA Books Set in – AZ, CO, NM, UT, WY
- Decades Challenge – Books Set in the 1900s and 1910s
- Book Voyage – Books Set in Western Europe
- Lifetime – Books with Teenage Main Characters
*We’ve used asterisks below to note which challenge list the book originally appeared on
The Last Bookshop in London
Book Summary
In 1939, Grace and her best friend, Liv, move to London and live with Grace’s late mother’s best friend, Mrs. Weatherford, and her son, Colin. While Grace isn’t a reader, she ends up with a job at Primrose Hill Books and works hard to clean and organize the messy store in hopes of earning the recommendation letter she needs to get the job she really wants at Harrods.
A customer named George helps Grace discover the magic of reading, and she’s soon hooked. Unfortunately, in 1940, the Blitz began, and daily life changed for every Londoner. While Grace continues her time at the bookshop, she also becomes an ARP (Air Raid Precautions) warden and is known for reading books aloud in tube stations during air raids. Will Primrose Hill Books survive this difficult period?
The Book Girls Say…
This novel is inspired by the true World War II history of the few bookshops to survive the Blitz. It’s said to be a great look into the life of brave Londoners during this tragic period at at the impact of war on average citizens.
While there are sad topics in the book, reviews say they appreciate that it manages to still be a heartwarming read with a good amount of focus on the bookstore.
The Paris Bookshop for the Broken-Hearted
Book Summary
Coco is having the worst month of her life. She lost her boyfriend and business, and she and her teen daughter had to move back in with her parents in Paris. Now, a handsome stranger is yelling at her under the Eiffel Tower!
Later that day, Coco discovers an old bookshop run by the mysterious Valerie. The store includes a café, cocktail bar, reading room, and even a secret tunnel of books. The store is intended to be a haven for the broken-hearted. It feels like a dream when Coco is offered a job as a bookseller in this magical shop. But then, she realizes that the grump who yelled at her earlier in the day is one of her new co-workers.
The Book Girls Say…
Reviewers compare the level of romance in this book to that of authors like Abby Jimenez, who put a lot of focus on the characters finding themselves outside of the relationship.
The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry
Book Girls’ Readers Rate This Book
Book Summary
Alice Island bookstore owner A.J. Fikry is having a terrible year. His wife has died, the store isn’t making enough sales, and his beloved book of Poe poems has been stolen. As a result, he’s cranky and pushing those around him away more than ever. Luckily he has a few people that look past his curmudgeonly attitude.
His depression reaches the point that he no longer enjoys books. But, sometimes, life gives you second chances in unexpected ways. For A.J., it’s a small, but heavy, mysterious package that arrives at his shop. As he begins to see the world around him in a new way, those around him can see him in a new way, too.
The Book Girls Say…
This gem of a book is only 260 pages, so perfect if you’re short on time and still looking for an impactful read.
The Storied Life of AJ Fikry was also released as a movie. It would be fun to read with a friend and then watch together.
Also Featured on These Book Lists:
Books with Characters In Their 30s
Books Set in the 2010s
Massachusetts Books: Novels Set in the Bay State
The Bookshop Book
Book Summary
In this 273-page non-fiction read, you’ll armchair travel to visit independent bookstores and their proprietors on six different continents.
From a tiny shop on a bike to a bookshop on a boat, you’ll fall in love with the quirky stores and their owners. Throughout the pages, you’ll also find lovely bookish quotes, interviews, and trivia.
The Book Girls Say…
This book is sure to inspire some new travel destinations for your bucket list! About half the book is set in the UK, with the remainder highlighting shops around the world.
If you enjoy humor writing, the author also has another non-fiction title, Weird Things Customers Say in Bookshops, that will make you laugh and roll your eyes at the funny things customers ask.
Midnight at the Bright Ideas Bookstore
Book Summary
Looking for an eerie mystery that’s perfect for book lovers? This highly-rated debut novel follows a bookshop employee named Lydia, who ends up investigating the suicide of one of her bookshop regulars.
As Lydia delves into his past, she also uncovers a buried memory from her own violent childhood. This twisty crime thriller with a very creative puzzle element that will keep readers guessing.
The Book Girls Say…
Colorado-based readers will recognize the Bright Ideas bookstore as The Tattered Cover. The author was a bookseller at this Denver book institution during the 1990s and used the store as his inspiration.
Also Featured on These Book Lists:
With Love from London
Book Summary
When Valentia was a teenager, her mother, Eloise, abandoned her and her father to start a new life in London. Now in her 30s, Val is a librarian and recently divorced. As she reevaluates her life, she realizes that the lack of closure with her mother is still nagging at her. But in a bittersweet twist of fate, Val learns that her mother has passed away before they’ve had a chance to reconcile.
Val is surprised to discover that Eloise left her a Primrose Hill apartment and the deed to a bookshop that Val never knew her mom owned. Determined to piece together a better understanding of Eloise’s life, Val decides to leave Seattle for a fresh start in London. It doesn’t take long for her to fall in love with the pastel-colored flat in a cozy neighborhood, not to mention the quaint bookstore. Unfortunately, she soon learns that The Book Garden is in financial trouble.
Told from a dual-timeline perspective, this book explores Valentia’s new life in London, as well as her mother’s past and what happened when she left her daughter behind.
The Book Girls Say…
Although the cover of this 2022 release says “sweet rom-com,” this is actually more of a feel-good story about mothers and daughters.
Sarah Jio also authored Goodnight June, another dual-timeline novel set in a Seattle bookstore. You’ll find that book on the recommendation list for a different prompt in the Book Lover’s Reading Challenge, but it would also make a good choice as a book about a bookstore.
Also Featured on These Book Lists:
The Forgotten Bookshop in Paris
Book Summary
With WWII war closing in on their city, Jacques’ wife is forced into hiding. Desperate to hold onto something, Jacques focuses all of his effort on saving his beloved bookshop. But when a woman and her child show up at his door one night begging for refuge, he can’t say no.
In present-day Paris, Juliette and her husband are supposed to be on a romantic getaway, but instead, she quickly discovers how far they’ve grown apart. When she comes across an abandoned bookshop with a for-sale sign in the window, she thinks it might just be the new adventure she’s craving. But the bookstore hides a lot more than meets the eye.
The Book Girls Say…
If you’ve already read this novel and are looking for another WW2 Historical Fiction set in Paris that includes a bookshop, try The Paris Daughter by Kristin Harmel.
Also Featured on These Book Lists:
The Bookshop Ladies
Book Summary
Joy’s French husband has passed away, and she has no idea why he has left a valuable painting to a woman named Robyn on the western coast of Ireland. So, she decides to deliver the painting in person.
When she arrives in Ballycove, she finds that Robyn runs a chaotic and unprofitable bookshop and desperately needs assistance. Joy soon becomes entangled not only in the bookshop but also in the town. All the while, she’s still trying to discover the secrets behind her late husband’s painting.
The Book Girls Say…
While this book is not part of a series, if you’ve read other Faith Hogan books set in Ballycove, like The Ladies Midnight Swimming Club, you might recognize a few familiar faces.
Readers say this is a cozy, found family story despite having some heavier themes of grief.
An Irish Bookshop Murder
Book Summary
Mercy and her twin-sister Lizzie are the new proprietors of an antique bookshop in the tiny Irish village of Shamrock Cove. However, their new venture takes a dark turn when Mercy finds their neighbor dying on his doorstep. Worse, he accuses her of murder before he dies, and several people hear him!
She has to quickly investigate to try and clear her name. As she looks through the victim’s old books, she finds that the local pub landlord, the kindly cook, and a neighborly knitter all had a reason to want the man dead. But, when Mercy’s top suspect also dies and leaves behind a threatening note typed on paper from Mercy’s new bookstore, things get even more complicated.
The Book Girls Say…
The additional books in this cozy mystery series also follow bookish storylines.
Bloomsbury Girls
Book Summary
Set in post-war London, Bloomsbury Girls focuses on an old-fashioned bookstore that has been run by men for a hundred years. However, by 1950, the world is changing in many ways.
Three of the shop girls, Vivien, Grace, and Evie, have their own big dreams that are intersected by fascinating interactions with famous literary figures. As they work in the shop, they plot out a future bigger than 1950 society generally allows.
The Book Girls Say…
This is a slow-paced, character-driven read. It’s a great one to cozy up and learn about three strong women in post-war London, but keep in mind it does not have a page-turning plot.
While this is listed as the second book in the Jane Austen Society, it does work as a stand-alone read.
Also Featured on These Book Lists:
Words in Deep Blue
Book Summary
Childhood friends Rachel & Henry grew apart when Rachel moved, and Henry didn’t respond to a confession of her love that she left behind for him in a book.
Now, Rachel has moved back and is struggling with the death of her sister. She gets a job at the bookshop owned by Henry’s family, and is closed off to him as she still feels rejected. What she didn’t know is that Henry’s life is also going through a rough patch – his girlfriend broke up with him, and the bookshop is slipping away as his family breaks apart.
But as Rachel & Henry work together, they begin exchanging letters through the pages of books in the store. Can they find new hope in each other?
The Book Girls Say…
While the main character is experiencing grief in the book, reviewers say they still ultimately put the book down feeling uplifted.
Words in Deep Blue won many awards, including the Prime Minister’s Literary Award for Young Adult Fiction in 2017.
The Borrow a Bookshop Holiday
Book Summary
Jude is twenty-nine and just graduated, so she can finally be public about her relationship with philosophy professor, Mack. She’s looking forward to their upcoming dream holiday to run a tiny bookshop in the harbor village of Clove Lore.
Two weeks before the non-refundable trip, Jude sees Mack kissing someone else. Luckily, there’s no better place to heal a broken heart than a bookshop. Jude takes the trip and expects to have some peace alone at the store, but finds another vacationing shopkeeper, Elliot, who seems to be hiding something.
The Book Girls Say…
While this book is classified as a romance, some readers struggle with that aspect because they don’t find Jude to be overly likable. However, everyone seems to enjoy both the bookshop elements and the light mystery as you try to figure out Elliot’s past.
If the idea of trading in your life for two weeks to run a bookshop in coastal England is appealing, you’ll love this series! The fifth book, A New Chapter at the Borrow a Bookshop, has a publication date of 1/23/25, so if you’ve already read the first four books, you can pick up the new release for the challenge!
The Bookseller
Book Summary
By day, Kitty is a single woman who owns a bookstore in Denver with her best friend, Frieda. In 1962, it was unconventional for a woman of her age to be an unmarried business owner, but she enjoyed having complete control over her day-to-day life without a husband to answer to. However, there was a man in her life once that she might have considered marrying—a doctor named Kevin.
But at night, Kitty leads an alternate life in her dreams. In this dream reality, Kitty goes by Katharyn, and the year is 1963. She’s married to the love of her life, a man named Lars. Together they live in an elegant Denver home and have triplets.
This life is everything that she once thought she wanted, and at first, Kitty enjoys her nightly visits to this alternate reality. But soon, Kitty begins to find Katharyn’s life irresistible. As the lines between her real life and her dream life begin to blur, she wonders if she can choose the life she wants – and if so, at what cost?
The Book Girls Say…
The Bookseller is set right in Book Girl Angela’s own little neighborhood in Denver! Locals will recognize Platt Park’s Old South Pearl Street during its cable car days and will enjoy stepping back in time to a decade when the University Hills were considered a southern suburb.
Cynthia Swanson also authored Anyone But Her, a dual-timeline novel that takes place in Denver in 1979 and 2004 and centers around a Colfax Avenue record shop owned by the mother of an East High School student.
Also Featured on These Book Lists:
The Rachel Incident
Book Summary
University student Rachel works at a bookstore, where she meets James, who quickly becomes her new BFF and roommate. The duo runs the streets of Cork, striving for a Bohemian lifestyle but also sharply aware of a looming financial collapse.
When Rachel falls for her married professor, Dr. Fred Byrne, she plots to seduce him after a reading at her bookstore. However, Fred has other desires that launch a series of secrets and compromises that intertwine the fates of James, Rachel, Fred, and Fred’s glamorous, well-connected wife.
The Book Girls Say…
Reviewers say this book is spicy and provocative, so consider whether that is something you enjoy in your reading before selecting this one. It’s also a strong character-driven literary read with more subtle happenings than page-turning plot points. However, it’s a great pick for those interested in stepping into the life of a modern young woman in Ireland.
Born and raised in Cork, Ireland, author Caroline O’Donoghue now calls London home. Speaking about her hometown in an interview, she says, “Cork is goth. … It was like that when I was growing up, and it’s like that now.”
Also Featured on These Book Lists:
The Paris Novel
Book Summary
When her estranged mother passed away, Stella received a one-way ticket and a note reading, “Go to Paris.” While she is much more comfortable living within her strict routines, her boss encourages her to go on the trip.
In Paris, Stella continues to live as cautiously and frugally as she does at home until she stumbles upon a Dior dress in a vintage store. When the shopkeeper insists that it was meant for Stella, she impulsively purchases the dress and it launches a new outlook on life.
When Stella meets Jules, an octogenarian art collector, he takes her under his wing and shows her the best of the literary, art, and culinary worlds of 1980s Paris.
The Book Girls Say…
Both Book Girls read and enjoyed this character-driven novel. When Angela first started reading it, life was busy, and she was only getting in about 10 or 15 minutes at a time and found it hard to connect to the story, but as soon as she sat with the book for a longer chunk of time, she found herself drawn in.
This novel includes many of our favorite things – food, art history, fashion, and books (including interactions with real-life authors at the famous Shakespear and Company bookstore) – all set in the City of Light.
If you’re looking for more books set in Paris, be sure to check out these lists: Best Novels Set in Paris and Rom Com & Romance Books Set in Paris.
Also Featured on These Book Lists:
24 Best Books Set in Paris
Books Set in the 1980s
Book Club Books for Summer 2024
March Crossover Books
Coming February 21st